- cypherpunks-legacy - lists.cpunks.org

Robin Hoods of Cyberspace: A Philosopher Examines the Difference Between Good and Bad Hackers
by Matthew Gaylor 04 Mar '01

04 Mar '01

This article from NYTimes.com http://www.nytimes.com/2001/03/04/technology/04HACKER.html Robin Hoods of Cyberspace: A Philosopher Examines the Difference Between Good and Bad Hackers March 4, 2001 Reviewed by STEVEN JOHNSON It can sometimes seem as if the number of people who have speculated on the social implications of Linux, the free computer operating system collectively engineered by thousands of programmers worldwide, exceeds the number of people who have actually used Linux itself. Ever since the open-source software movement entered into the public consciousness in the late 90's, we've been awash in prophesies about the end of the Windows era and the birth of a less proprietary digital age. Together, the emergence of open-source software and the related Napster music file sharing system constitute the most significant technological development since the arrival of the World Wide Web. Up to now, most ruminations on the impact of open-source software have limited their view to the computer desktop itself: does the stability of the Linux platform prove that open software development models are intrinsically more stable than the proprietary ones used by Microsoft? Is there an economic model that can support the development of free software? These are important questions, but they don't do justice to the most remarkable fact about the open-source movement: at the very epicenter of New Economy capitalism, something that looks a great deal like a wired version of communism has prospered beyond anyone's wildest imagination. While private companies are free to sell ''flavors'' of Linux, and to sell technical support, no one owns Linux proper. It belongs to the people. If the Web served as a launching pad for the Xtreme capitalism heralded in magazines like Fast Company and Wired, the launching pad itself was partly built by freely contributed collective labor. Itself something of a collaborative project, ''The Hacker Ethic: And the Spirit of the Information Age'' begins with the premise that the programmers behind the open-source movement (called ''hackers'' throughout the book) represent a ''spiritual challenge to our time.'' As Pekka Himanen writes in his preface, ''the hacker ethic is a new work ethic that challenges the attitude toward work that has held us in its thrall for so long, the Protestant work ethic, as explicated in Max Weber's classic 'The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism.' '' ''The Hacker Ethic'' begins with a breezy prologue from the legendary programmer behind the Linux revolution, Linus Torvalds, centered on what he calls ''Linus's Law.'' (His theory: people are motivated by ''survival,'' ''social life'' and ''entertainment.'') Himanen, a philosopher of technology who teaches at the University of Helsinki and at the University of California, Berkeley, then presents a longer essay -- the bulk of the book, really -- on the core attributes of the hacker ethic, contrasting them with Weber's work and that of his modern disciples. The techno-sociologist Manuel Castells arrives in the closing pages to deliver a somewhat freeze-dried rendition of his grand theory on the difference between today's ''network society'' and the industrial systems of yore. Because Torvalds's contributions are so slender, and because Castells has presented his ideas elsewhere, ''The Hacker Ethic'' needs to be judged primarily on the substance of Himanen's argument: that the values associated with the open-source movement present a significant challenge to the Protestant ethic. While Himanen's text relies on almost no primary research in terms of interviewing programmers, his survey of the core components of the hacker ethic (which he calls the nethic) is as comprehensive and instructive as any to date. Unlike the dutiful labor of Weber's Protestant ethic, the nethic embraces flexible hours, creativity and a passion for one's work. The nethic also disdains monetary reward for one's achievements, preferring what the open-sourcers call Egoboo -- the respect of one's peers. While Himanen can present a strained image of hacker sainthood, he makes a persuasive case that the nethic stands in direct opposition to the Weberian tradition. But that opposition raises two questions. First, is the Protestant work ethic still a useful category in modern industrialized societies? Weber's theory had little room for today's frenzied leisure-time consumption. (Sunday was a day of rest -- not the day for PlayStation 2 and Old Navy.) We may be programming our TiVo's with time-management skills that would have made the efficiency expert Frederick Taylor proud, but surely there's a difference between using those techniques to tape episodes of ''Temptation Island'' and using them for crop rotation. The dominant culture may still be clinging to older, Weberian notions of labor-as-duty, but it certainly spends a great deal of energy persuading us to kick back and live a little on the weekend. Himanen avoids dealing with the prominence of today's consumer society by wishing it away with the old ''false consciousness'' dismissals: ''Only when work uses up all energy and people are too tired to enjoy the pursuit of their passions are they ready to be reduced to the passively receptive state suited for television.'' In other words, that feeling you have of actually enjoying ''Seinfeld'' reruns -- that's just an illusion. But even if you accept Himanen's most optimistic scenario -- a band of impassioned hackers challenging the oppressive establishment -- the question remains: What does it mean for the rest of us? Can the playful, work-for-art's-sake nethic be transferred to the analog world? For anyone who is excited about the promise of the open-source revolution, that may well be the most provocative question of all, and Himanen has meager answers for it. ''The hacker open model,'' he writes, ''could be transformed into a social model -- call it the open-resource model -- in which someone announces: I have an idea, I can contribute this much to it, please join me! . . . For example, I could announce on the Net that I would be willing, once in a while, to help some elderly person take care of things. I can announce that kids can come and play at our house after school.'' This is a nice idea, but hardly a radical break from, say, a real-world bulletin board at a community center. Himanen has a powerful grasp on that strangely intoxicating contradiction that is open-source, but when it comes to potential extensions of that model, he falls short. You can't help being let down to find that a mainstream adoption of the hacker ethic might only make it easier to find a baby sitter for the kids. Steven Johnson is the co-founder of Feedmag.com and the author of ''Interface Culture.'' His next book, ''Emergence,'' will be published in September. /-----------------------------------------------------------------\ Visit NYTimes.com for complete access to the most authoritative news coverage on the Web, updated throughout the day. Become a member today! It's free! http://www.nytimes.com?eta Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company ************************************************************************** Subscribe to Freematt's Alerts: Pro-Individual Rights Issues Send a blank message to: freematt(a)coil.com with the words subscribe FA on the subject line. List is private and moderated (7-30 messages per week) Matthew Gaylor, 2175 Bayfield Drive, Columbus, OH 43229 (614) 313-5722 ICQ: 106212065 Archived at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/fa/ **************************************************************************

1 0

Microsoft Trial Judge Based His Break-Up "Remedy" On Flawed Theory, Not Facts
by Matthew Gaylor 04 Mar '01

04 Mar '01

23 58

Would you like to make money on the internet?
by Dynamic Service 04 Mar '01

04 Mar '01

Start earning $20-$200 every day, working less than 30 minutes a day on your computer. No obligation, limited time offer! Act NOW and you'll get our $295 Internet Income course ABSOLUTELY FREE. If interested reply with YES in the subject line. This is the only time you'll receive this great opportunity. Thank you for your time. Dynamic Service

1 0

Into: Cash By Fax
by cashbyfax2412231＠aol.com 04 Mar '01

04 Mar '01

hi there, please take a moment to check out the newest cash offer. cash is waiting for you! Click Below Or copy the link and paste it in your browser http://www.geocities.com/arushhour6767/

1 0

NEWEST CRAZE
by znewmarketing34789＠hotmail.com 04 Mar '01

04 Mar '01

Hey...Janet Here... We Haven't Talked In So Long!! How Have You Been? Thought I would Forward you this email! I usually delete these but I opened this one, like what I saw, and thought you would like to see this. http://www.geocities.com/anewmarket9090/ IF THE LINK IS NOT HIGHLIGHTED OR YOU CANNOT CLICK ON IT. COPY AND PASTE IT IN YOUR BROWSER.

1 0

Mixmaster ate my messages!!
by A. Melon 04 Mar '01

04 Mar '01

What's up with the mixmaster list from publius.net? Why are half the remailers down, have the dead remailers been compromised? I'm down to using just five remailers if I want to get my message thru! Is there a better list? Can I make my own lists? This is the list of reliable mixmasters. Last update: Wed 28 Feb 101 6:16:54 PST mixmaster history latency uptime -------------------------------------------- austria **-**+**+*** 12:05 100.00% <-- dizum **-********* 13:35 99.99% <-- randseed **-+++++++-- 38:33 99.98% <-- shinn **-********* 13:55 99.98% <-- squirrel ----------++ 1:34:39 99.94% noisebox ++-+*++*++++ 24:59 99.93% <-- farout ----------- 8:17:25 99.84% riot ----------- 5:40:34 99.34% cmeclax -...-.-...- 21:54:53 99.29% lcs +--+++--++ 1:03:18 99.03% passthru _.-+---- -- 3:02:10 98.64% cracker ------. - + 2:13:16 97.89% bruble2 _ 158:04:25 47.34% septic 10:06:11 0.00% xganon 2:31:21 0.00% bilgates 1:31:07 0.00% arick 1:19:12 0.00% mix 17:45:02 0.00% hyper2 3:22:56 0.00% orange 1:41:01 0.00% stealth 32:31 0.00% cracow 65:12:15 0.00% rot13 40:19:05 0.00% History key # response in less than 5 minutes. * response in less than 1 hour. + response in less than 4 hours. - response in less than 24 hours. . response in less than 2 days. _ response in more than 2 days.

1 0

Slashdot | Intel Claims 10Ghz Transistor
by Jim Choate 04 Mar '01

04 Mar '01

http://slashdot.org/articles/01/03/04/1336231.shtml -- ____________________________________________________________________ Before a larger group can see the virtue of an idea, a smaller group must first understand it. "Stranger Suns" George Zebrowski The Armadillo Group ,::////;::-. James Choate Austin, Tx /:'///// ``::>/|/ ravage(a)ssz.com www.ssz.com .', |||| `/( e\ 512-451-7087 -====~~mm-'`-```-mm --'- --------------------------------------------------------------------

1 0

Porn Star Celebs! => cypherpunks@toad.com
by editor＠newsletter.join4free.com 04 Mar '01

04 Mar '01

CLUB T.A. See the newest and most popular stars in adult entertainment. The women that have appeared in Penthouse, Playboy, Vivid Videos, plus more.... Watch These Erotic Women Maximize Full Pleasure! http://refer.ccbill.com/cgi-bin/clicks.cgi?CA=902932&PA=102010 AOL USERS: <a href=http://refer.ccbill.com/cgi-bin/clicks.cgi?CA=902932&PA=102010">Click Here</a> We can't emphasize it enough...you must see this for yourself. The live sex shows are just one of many ways for you to fullfill your quest! Amazing never seen before photos and a library so large of nothing but xxx videos! Click Here & Get Your Trial Pass To CLUB T.A. http://refer.ccbill.com/cgi-bin/clicks.cgi?CA=902932&PA=102010 AOL USERS: <a href=http://refer.ccbill.com/cgi-bin/clicks.cgi?CA=902932&PA=102010">Click Here</a> ************************************************************************************************************* Note: this is not a spam email. This email was sent to you because your email was entered in on a website requesting to be a registered subscriber. If you did not request this email, please use the link below to unsubscribe: http://www.join4free.com/cancel.html?p=cypherpunks&job=983649439&email=cyph… and you will *never* receive another email from us! *************************************************************************************************************

1 0

You have no idea
by Nomen Nescio 04 Mar '01

04 Mar '01

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- aimee.farr(a)pobox.com (Aimee Elizabeth Farr) recited: >Of course, you have all watched this battle for many years, so you >have a longevity of insight that I don't have. Probably just the >same-ole-same-ole to you... Believe me, you have NO idea. Then, aimee.farr(a)pobox.com (Aimee Elizabeth Farr) recited: >I can't figure out if you're irked by amateurish elicitation >tactics, or if you're trying to give me lessons in how to do better. I think you can probably figure it out. Ah, I remember the days when I was wet behind the ears on this list. The collision between the law and cypherpunks certainly creates an interesting reaction. -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: PGP 7.0.1 iQEVAwUBOp17Oy1onm9OaF05AQHKZQgAiyNUYn7M9AW71MFXk6wE3fEOWoWi0Mdk urAZq0EypCrlh94lBc9CPshY3ZDFOTYhzykMT9fa9OnlkwU3L9J4f7gFtI7VAFxF CxxWoc7XAMXlNd0OrXYIebK7OAb0LFVK/f/xs3yfwqkPMTj/N3uWJNB/E2JXTMu+ lcXxFzRUQ13gMuo123jq951iAeIUUzL96kyYWnuGhxsewaK8evWW4Iuy2ikGvZL3 H75UuwWtNAmHci++N3t8YedkuOHUj28cdsxpDT3tPTlhk88hd+peVhTsrt5wOnEF gGz7FeXX6JXfNLWk23ErpRUe5OhI0xnm4uhdlM9dx3E618VbXkd9VA== =DCYR -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

2 1

ebay restricting DVD player sales -RIAA tentacles
by Blank Frank 03 Mar '01

03 Mar '01

The company [EBay] also has instituted a policy to prohibit the sale of anything recorded on a blank compact disc, and it stops sales of certain types of DVD players and gaming equipment that can be used with illegally copied media. http://www.usatoday.com/life/cyber/tech/2001-02-28-ebay.htm The RIAA must have some very scary lawyers.

6 5