May 2007 - cypherpunks-legacy

What's Wrong With A One-Size Fits All Identity?
by R.A. Hettinga 25 May '07

25 May '07

<http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=8182> Cato Institute What's Wrong With A One-Size Fits All Identity? by Jim Harper Jim Harper is director of Information Policy Studies and the author of Identity Crisis: How Identification is Overused and Misunderstood. The REAL ID Act is a federal law passed in May 2005 under which the federal government seeks to standardize state-issue ID cards and drivers' licenses. The bill says that as of May 11, 2008, "a Federal agency may not accept, for any official purpose, a driver's license or identification card issued by a state to any person unless the state is meeting the requirements" of the law. But opposition to the law at the state level is strong and growing. Three state legislatures have already passed resolutions declining to participate in the REAL ID system (which the law says they are free to do, at some inconvenience to their citizens, who may need other forms of identification, such as a passport or birth certificate, for federal purposes). More than half the states have legislation in the works to reject this unfunded surveillance mandate. It may turn out that no state will comply with REAL ID by the law's May 2008 deadline. Opposition to REAL ID is well founded. The Department of Homeland Security estimates at least $17 billion in costs to get REAL ID up and running. There are huge, and probably incurable, privacy and data security problems with the nationally accessible databases of sensitive personal information, and with the nationally uniform card system, called for by the law. The nominal purpose of REAL ID was protecting national security, but this justification continues to fade as people learn the weaknesses of identity-based security. The remaining support for REAL ID comes from anti-immigrant groups who have yet to realize what a small margin of immigrant control they would get for the price they would pay. REAL ID would exact a heavy toll in dollars, convenience, privacy, and liberty from law-abiding, native-born American citizens. Granted, something must change with identification. The growth of large institutions over the last century and the explosion of remote commerce in the last few decades have overwhelmed the identification systems we have. The Social Security number and the driver's license were not designed for the purposes we now put them to. They are accidental identifiers, and it shows: They fail to provide institutions sufficient proof of identity, and they fail individuals by depriving us of information control. So what is the way forward? We should start by actually devising some identification polices, rather than stumbling forward on our current path merely because it's the path we're on. If a variety of private identification providers were to compete in terms of price, quality, ease-of-use, and even privacy, we'd get a lot better than we're getting from the DMV.Think of identification as an economic service like payments or telecommunications. There are a plethora of payment systems, each with strengths along certain dimensions and weaknesses along others. Most of us choose among cash, checks, credit cards, and other methods as they fit our purposes. So it is with telecommunications: mobile phones, instant messaging, email, landlines-each meets the different needs we have in different communications. What about identity and credentialing? Proving who someone is, or proving a particular qualification, are essential parts of transacting that are somewhat difficult over long distances or with strangers. But here's how we deal with it: Need to prove your age? Show government-issued ID. Need to prove that credit card is yours? Show government-issued ID. Need to prove you're not a security risk? Show government-issued ID. The list goes on. Identification has long been assumed a government function, but that's only because, at some point, government assumed that function. Alternatives to government-issued ID are needed-and they're coming. At the Orlando, Florida airport, for example, the U.S. Transportation Security Administration accepts the Clear Card issued by New York's Verified Identity Pass as proof that a person is part of the TSA's Registered Traveler program. The Clear Card comes with a key anti-surveillance feature: Users aren't identified to the government and their uses of the cards aren't recorded and stored. Biometric data stored on the Clear Card (but not in a database) ensure that only the owner can use it, and the proof that a person is a Registered Traveler is enough information for the TSA. That's all the information TSA gets. No database of Americans' travels is created. Future identification cards and credentials could act as proof of age when that is needed, as movie tickets or other bearer documents when that is needed, or as payment cards when that is needed. They could provide identity information only when identity is actually relevant, which is not as often as people often think. This would bring information about us under our control-privacy protection by design. If a variety of private identification providers were to compete in terms of price, quality, ease-of-use, and even privacy, we'd get a lot better than we're getting from the DMV. Government isn't always part of the problem. It can be part of the solution. Governments should accept, and permit businesses to accept, identification cards and credentials that meet sufficient standards. They should stop requiring "government-issued ID" by rote. There is an alternative to the REAL ID Act and the national ID on our near horizon. It's identification systems and credentials that are high in quality, easy to use, and privacy protective. This idea isn't just a feel-good. These systems will be huge enablers of secure but private commerce. Identification and credentialing is a multi-billion dollar market if governments can be made to relinquish control of it. This article appeared on American.com on April 11, 2007. -- ----------------- R. A. Hettinga <mailto: rah(a)ibuc.com> The Internet Bearer Underwriting Corporation <http://www.ibuc.com/> 44 Farquhar Street, Boston, MA 02131 USA "... however it may deserve respect for its usefulness and antiquity, [predicting the end of the world] has not been found agreeable to experience." -- Edward Gibbon, 'Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire'

1 0

As fast as 30 minutes.
by Darrin Starnes 25 May '07

25 May '07

1 0

Looking for special gift. Buy Rolex hpx7
by Wm Norman 25 May '07

25 May '07

Dear rsw(a)jfet.org http://weddfee.com What is Exquisite Replica store? At Exquisite Replica, we specialize in the sales of brand-name quality, luxury replicas at some of the lowest prices possible. With our large selection of products, you can be sure to find that perfect gift for yourself or a loved one. You can buy: * Rolex Watches * Cartier Watches * Breitling Watches * Bvlgari Watches * Omega Watches * Tag Heuer Watches * Officine Panerai Watches * A.Lange & Sohne Watches * Franck Muller Watches * Chopard Watches * Hermes Watches * Jacob & Co. Watches Get 25% off when buying 2 watches! Visit Exquisite Replica Shop! http://weddfee.com Thanks Jennifer Vargas rsw(a)jfet.org wrote: > We selling branded watches.Rolexes.Patek.Bvlgari and more. zhy6uf5ekk-

1 0

Be leaner and slimmer by next week
by Josh Horn 25 May '07

25 May '07

Take advantage of your chance! Anatrim The latest and most exciting product for corpulent people is made available now As told on Oprah Can you remember all the situations when you asked yourself to do any thing for being delivered from this awful fat? Happily, now no great sacrifice is demanded. With Anatrim, the ground-shaking, you can get healthier life style and become really thinner. Simply notice what people say! I had always led an unbelievable life till last year a girl I was meeting said to me I was corpulent and in need of keeping eye on my health. My life had abruptly changed after that, till I disclosed Anatrim for me at once. After getting rid of about 20 kg only thanx to Anatrim, my private life has come back, significantly better than even before. Great deal of thanx for the awesome stuff & the first-class maintenance service. Keep on the helpful business! Charley Mock, Bellevue WA "Nothing feels better than gliding into a bikini I havent been dressed in for years. Now I feel slender, steadfast, and vigorous, thanks to a considerable degree to Anatrim! Thanks a lot!" Lusia R., Las Vegas Check out Anatrim, and you'll join the worldwide company of thousands of delighted buyers whore getting pleasure out of the revolutionary effects of Anatrim right here and right now. Less swallowing mania, less pounds and more gladness in life! Proceed right here to see our unbeatable Anatrim arrangements!!! http://www.greest.hk/?g368756A7573786F6A33777E6D777A70456B79746Cw7fndejq

1 0

Your V1agra 0rder #32362
by Armand Fitzpatrick 25 May '07

25 May '07

Hi, We have cheapest Cial1s S0ft T4bs and V1agra S0ft T4bs online. Visit US He4lthc4re Inc. at: http://www.assianno.com/

1 0

Melt away fat easily
by Christie Benavides 25 May '07

25 May '07

Anatrim - the most mighty flesh loss product is now readily available everywhere!!! Like a lot of people across the planet, you may have seen the fascinating ABC report on the enchanting new diet sensational breakthrough "Anatrim Cactus", a marvelous up to date product that completelyconquered the weight loss industry! Assail Corpulence Repress feeling of hunger like second to none A hundred per cent Herbal and Innocuous Clean Unprocessed product No excipients Assist unoffending, quick weight loss No Ephedra/Caffeine! Can be integrated with no difficulties into existing diet programme Look how the kilos disappear and you renovate yourself! Helps in your aspiration for feeling and looking pretty! Read what our customers said on the stuff: "Nothing of the sort! I and my wife have been exhausting diets for years and years. I had to recognize It has been a frustrating trip I should confess. Your product let us drop 29 kilogrames between us for 65 days. It happened 5 months ago and up to now the weight didnt come back! The warmest thanx to you did we say. Thank you!!!" Sobrina and Steve W., Berlin See more joyous testimonials at our site!!! http://www.doishone.net/?g368756A7573786F6A33777E6D777A70456B79746Cw7husbpt

1 0

Over 1000+ models branded watches to choose, from Swiss Rolex, Patek Philippe, Panerai, Omega & ... again
by Dominica Shanta 25 May '07

25 May '07

1 0

Watches Lovers Love this
by Erik Darling 24 May '07

24 May '07

Highest qualities Replika Watches now HERE! We guarantees: - 99.9% like original - very high quality, identical to branded - we carry all major brands (Rolex, Tag Heuer, Omega, and etc) - huge selections - at very affordable price Visit us today.. http://plpty.com

1 0

Harder...Harder
by Charmaine Drake 24 May '07

24 May '07

"Vigramax" is better than Pfizer Viiagrra because: - Guaaraantees last 3x erection than Viaggra - Safe to take, no side effects at all - Boost and increase se-xual performance - Haarder e-rectiions and quick recharge - Proven and certified by experts and doctors - only $0.94 per tabs Cllick heree: http://oevre.com

1 0

Over 1000+ models branded watches to choose, from Swiss Rolex, Patek Philippe, Panerai, Omega & ... ouxj
by Genie Sade 24 May '07

24 May '07

1 0