[Isod-rg] OGF ISOD-RG use case document

[Chin Guok]

HI Joan, Alex,

This is great feedback.  I would like in incorporate your ideas into the 
document.

Would it be useful to change the the subsection of "Characteristics" to 
"Service Characteristics", and have another subsection called "Resource 
Characteristics" that reflect the additions that you are thinking off?

Thanks again for contributing to the document.

- Chin

On 9/14/11 6:12 AM, Joan A. Garcia-Espin wrote:
> Thanks for your answer Alex, my comments in-line below.
>
> BR,
> -- 
> Joan A. García-Espín
> DANA, Fundació i2CAT
>
>
> El 14/09/2011, a las 14:52, Alexander Willner escribió:
>
>> Hi there,
>>
>> On 14.09.2011, at 13:04, Joan A. Garcia-Espin wrote:
>>> Another thing I would like to discuss is how we could adapt or 
>>> include the networking flavour into IaaS (mainly)
>>
>> what about listing available infrastructure components (cpu, storage, 
>> network, ...) and list their specific properties and 
>> interdependencies in detail. In case of an IaaS you've very low level 
>> access to a (virtual) network and network devices.
>
>
>>> to PaaS
>>
>> What about "nPaaS" (Network PaaS): here you can specify network 
>> properties of your Application PaaS.
>
> My idea is: ok, a network domain has some properties (if managed) that 
> allows you to provide net services on top. Hence, one can see the net 
> domain as a "platform" for net services. This has implications in the 
> management and control functions of the domain: you need some generic 
> functions, and some tech-specific ones. Does this reasoning fit your 
> mind?
>
>>> and, why not, to SaaS.
>>
>> Mh, Network as a Software?
>
> Not this way, I am referring to "network software". Simple example: 
> the control plane and its behaviour. Complex example: programmable 
> networks. It is again related to control and management, but now in 
> thinking in the operation phase. Even more, using the Google App 
> Engine (one platform) one can run different apps simultaneously 
> (several sw pieces). Is this applicable to networking? How do we 
> re-define SaaS if so?
>
>> Just some thoughts, Alex
>
> More than welcomed!
>
>>
>> -- 
>> net.cs.bonn.edu/willner
>>
>>
>