[gin-data] Update Ftp transfers

Oxana Smirnova oxana.smirnova at hep.lu.se
Wed Aug 23 17:30:49 CDT 2006


Hi,

Gregor von Laszewski пишет:

> As explained in my previous mail the reason for the failures were 
> related to authentication. I would therefore conclude that something 
> went wrong during the process of getting into the VO (hategan and 
> kettimuthu). Hence, I do suggest that the process of getting into the VO 
> be reevaluated by someone outside of our group just to make sure that 
> there is no bug in the process.

I am not so sure this is the correct diagnostics: at least our server 
logs show the testers are properly authenticated

> Do you have some documentation on how this system is configured. I was 
> under the impression that if I know the gridftp server and the address I 
> should just be able to start communication with it. That is essentially 
> what we tested on TG where it seems to work.

Ours is not a Globus GridFTP server, and in this particular case it 
looks like some *old* Globus bug #1315 is acting up - Aleksandr (who 
reported the bug) may have more on it.

> I assume once the VO accounting issues are solved I am almost certain we 
> can just replicate the experiment. Is there any volunteer that has these 
> accounts already?

I am in GIN VO, and I am sure I have no *accounts* on any of those 
systems; yet here are my quick tests (pushing a 1MB file from my 
notebook all around the place):

- Imperial College (EGEE) : success
- Imperial College (London e-Science): failure because they didn't 
update IGTF certs for half a year or so
- UC San Diego (OSG) : success
- U of Chicago (Teragrid): failure, unable to connect at all
- Leeds, Oxford, Manchester, RAL (NGS): failure, permission denied, 
connection closed
- Lund (NorduGrid/ARC): success

And that's it, I see no other addresses to try in GIN Wiki. Basically, I 
got only one (1) authentication error, and that was because folks at IC 
did not update their security software for quite a while. For NGS sites, 
I suspect they advertise an incomplete path.

Cheers,
Oxana





More information about the gin-data mailing list