AG Barr: USG Seeks Front Door to Encryption Not Backdoor

[Zenaan Harkness]

On Fri, Oct 04, 2019 at 03:30:35PM -0400, John Young wrote:
> Attorney General William P. Barr Delivers Remarks at the Lawful Access Summit
> 
> https://www.justice.gov/opa/speech/attorney-general-william-p-barr-delivers-remarks-lawful-access-summit
> 
> "It is also said that the Government is seeking a secretive 'backdoor' to
> everyone's communications and data.  That is false.  We are seeking a front
> door.
> 
> The heart of the matter is this: Do the security advantages of warrant-proof
> encryption offered to the individual outweigh the risk posed to the public by
> that same technology?  This is not a decision for the companies to make by
> themselves.  It is a decision for society to make.
> 
> We think our tech sector has the ingenuity to develop effective ways to
> provide secure encryption while also providing secure legal access."


The fundamental misnomer or misunderstanding (if we are to take the
most generous interpretation of AG Barr's words) is that there is
some form of "secure legal access" which will not be abused by those
in power against those not in power.

: Such does not exist.

To be a little less "generous", it is the hubris of those in power
who project that mechanisms of control "granted" "willingly" "by the
electorate" to those in power, which causes their blindness.

The blindness includes the blindness to how ornery, but clear
thinking, individual humans hear the words such as AG Barr speaks
above.

Needless to say that around these parts, such stupidity (or, egain
generously, 'ignorance') does not go unnoticed.

The beginnings of a conversation by those in power which would go a
long way to encouraging a sane public dialogue, must include:

 - full and fair inclusion of -all- the issues of such "encryption
   front doors or backdoors", including but not limited to the
   endless abuse of power, by those in power, which we who are not in
   power witness on a weekly or daily basis.

 - the benefits to the majority by individual empowerment

 - our right to hold those in power accountable, and the absolute
   need for encryption which is secure AGAINST those currently in
   power, to so hold accountable those in power


Those presently in power, no matter who they are today or this year,
almost invariably seek more power, and seek tools to hold the
majority at bay and in subservience.

We the majority do not accept this.

And, we will not be deceived or deluded by the usual propaganda
suspects "terrorism" and "national security".


Freedom has a price, and a free people are ready and willing to pay
that price.

The cost we will pay for giving up our freedom is in the long term
far greater and entirely shocking to consider, when one considers how
government mandated control over every aspect of human life,
including private communications, must inevitably play out.


Those such as AG Barr who speak so superficially, with so little
(public) consideration of anything other than "the interest of the
state" (which is in majority the interests of existing power
structures, Corp, Gov, MIC, FED, Spy, Bank, etc), belie their own
compromised spirit, belie how far they have strayed from the actual
interests of the majority of humans.

Peace, and let's create our world,