Judy Miller needing killing

[Gil Hamilton]

Justin <justin-cypherpunks at soze.net>wrote:
>On 2005-10-19T19:59:18+0000, Gil Hamilton wrote:
> >
> > Reporters should have no rights the rest of us don't have.  It's hard to
> > imagine the framers of the constitution approving an amendment that said
> > freedom of the press is granted to all those who first apply for and
> > receive permission from the government.
>
>Blame the framers.  They separately enumerated freedom of speech and
>freedom of the press, which suggests at least a little bit that freedom
>of the press includes something extra.

Yes, it specifies printed material rather than spoken; this wouldn't have 
been unusual to them -- English law has long distinguished libel from 
slander, for example.  Your statement implies that you think the framers 
were being deliberately vague or encoding various sorts of subtle nuances in 
the amendment's language.  It's much simpler to presume that they said what 
they intended to say.

GH

_________________________________________________________________
Dont just search. Find. Check out the new MSN Search! 
http://search.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200636ave/direct/01/