[acs-wg] GGF15 minutes

[Sachiko Wada]

Hi team,

Here are the minutes of the GGF15 sessions.
Please review it and point out where the record is not correct, if any.

I will upload the minutes to the gridforge later.

Sachiko

======================================================================
GGF15 ACS Session #1
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Date and Time: Oct 5 14:00-15:30 EDT 2005
Lead:  Keisuke Fukui (Fujitsu)
Notes: Sachiko Wada (Ascade)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
We reviewed the ACS specification version 0.51.
https://forge.gridforum.org/projects/acs-wg/document/draft-ggf-acs-spec-0.51/en/1

* TOC
   no comments

(Chapter 1 and 2 was pushed after the rest of the draft.)

* Chapter 3
    We reviewed chapter 3 in the draft and OGSA EMS section posted by Mike.
    The comments from Pete and Sachiko and TBD items are covered and
    addressed in the draft.
  ACTION:
  - Mike, to reconfirm about comment D10 to Pete. (section 3.1.4)
  - Mike, to draw diagram for section 3.1.4 which describes multiple
      job creation from a single AA.
  Issues:
  - Consider if the digest values can be used to verify cached reference.

======================================================================
GGF15 ACS Session #2
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Date and Time: Oct 5 18:00-19:30 EDT 2005
Lead:  Keisuke Fukui (Fujitsu)
Notes: Sachiko Wada (Ascade)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
We continued reviewing the ACS specification.

* Chapter 3 (continued)
   We continued reviewing chapter 3.
   Hiro sent comments on section 3.3.4 and we adopted the comments.
  ACTION:
  - Mike, to change the diagram simpler since we need not describe
     whole EMS architecture. (section 3.3.4)
  Issues:
  - Revisit comment S18 and S20. (section 3.2.2)
  - Decide how we can address to the naming issues in the draft, i.e. which
    of the WS-Name or EPR to be used. OGSA seems to be moving to use WS-Name
    instead of EPR but have not reach consensus yet.

* Chapter 4
  ACTION:
  - Mike, to confirm to Pete weather the description of section 4.5 replication 
     is sufficient.
 
* Chapter 5
   Steve suggested specifying an ACS Fault type as base of other faults.
   Stuart suggested that whole tree structure of AAs should be retrieved
   from Application Repository. Currently users of ACS can retrieve
   the immediate parent and children of an AA.
  ACTION:
  - Mike, to rephrase the Steve's suggestion as an remained issue in ACS-WG.
  - Mike, to rephrase the Stuart's suggestion as an remained issue in ACS-WG.
  Issues:
  - Detailed discussion about resource properties. Should we add
     manageability properties ? This is related Manageability section.
  - TBD remained that whether we should use getAAD instead of
     GetResourceProperty in order to retrieve AAD.
  - Make clear that who (ApplicationRepository or ApplicationArchive)
     sends the Notification when AA is created and updated.

The list of the changes to the draft will be posted later. Also, the
updated version of the draft will be uploaded to the document manager.
The review of the remained chapters will be continued on the
tele-conferences aiming at the submission by the end of October.