[acs-wg] ACS considerations

[Keisuke Fukui (on the road)]

Tom,

Thanks for your comments.
Though we will also cover these and many are understandable, I and Sachiko
felt difficulty in understanding your comment below:

Thomas Studwell wrote:
> 
> Chart 4: User provides a collection of information and the AC and ADD 
> for a AA they wish to have created. They do not, as a Producer, generate 
> an AA per se, the exception is a case where the user wishes to create a 
> replica but I call this a Replicator function rather than a Producer 
> function (and very important reason that we agree on and keep the roles 
> distinct). We need to develop the type of information that needs to be 
> included in the collection but it has things like Description, Owner, 
> Access Rights, etc.
> 

Sachiko pointed me that there may be some discrepancy between us on
understanding the use cases here.
Does your comment above means (3) is your main use case?

FYI,
I thought the case (1) would be the bottom line one, then (2) will be
realized as a more value added form of the service implementations.
In my opinion, (3) is questionable because I don't see points here.
I understand that Mike and Sachiko is also doubtful about (3)
 > Slide 4: Agree about #3 not being needed.

We can discuss more at the next session.

  -Keisuke