You wrote:

Sounds like a heck of a good idea, if:

1. You can ID the bad logic with a high percent of success (90+ ?).

I shall endevor to do my best. Initially, I shall only comment on the most flagrant violations. 90+% should be easy.

2. You can comment/reply for all members fairly, but if> limited by the large number of postings (and fallacies ?), give priority to ???

Worst first.

As far as Congress expelling members, are you saying that the Senate and/or H.O.R. can permanently eliminate a person elected by the people?

Yes, the congress is the sole determiner of the qualifications of its members.

Has this ever been tested?

Adam Clayton Powell. Logos out