Re: Milgram & Authority (+Ethics)
Jeff Davis says:
March/April 1976- I'd just gotten divorced and the bullet hole in my abdomen was healing quite nicely. Really? I was under the impression his stuff had been published substantially before that date -- certainly that seems to be a quite late year for him to have been presenting a paper on it.
Stanley Milgram reorganized the very foundations of ethical human research with his experimental procedure. He was very active in structuring ethical human experimentation for years. That's why my question was phrased, "ethical questions aside..."
Some o' y'all don't know much about folks, do ya.
Jeff, Perry isn't questioning your description of Milgram's experiments, he was questioning the dates - '76 seems awfully late for that work to have been new and exciting (as opposed to old and exciting.) (Yes, that may imply he's questioning your credibility, or delving into deeper philosophical questions like whether you're really just another incarnation of Detweiler :-) On the other hand, it may be that the time you heard Milgram speaking wasn't the *first* time he'd given his talk - he's probably spoken on the topic a few gazillion times, especially if he's talking to college audiences...
bill.stewart@pleasantonca.ncr.com +1-510-484-6204 says:
On the other hand, it may be that the time you heard Milgram speaking wasn't the *first* time he'd given his talk - he's probably spoken on the topic a few gazillion times, especially if he's talking to college audiences...
Mr. Davis has stated that he heard him presenting his paper on the subject, which initially implied that Davis was there when Milgram was presenting the original research. Perry
participants (2)
-
Perry E. Metzger -
wcs@anchor.ho.att.com