As I delurk, a question... (Clipper)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- The thought occurs... the NSA doesn't seem particularly distressed that Clipper's LEAF can be spoofed and rendered unusable. Could this indicate that the LEAF isn't really necessary to retrieve the session key after all? - -- Roy M. Silvernail -- roy@sendai.cybrspc.mn.org will do just fine, thanks. "Does that not fit in with your plans?" -- Mr Wiggen, of Ironside and Malone (Monty Python) PGP 2.3a public key available upon request (send yours) -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: 2.3c iQCVAgUBLf0dkRvikii9febJAQFEGQP+JUs/Z67WyE2Xgd6dwwcarHrGUqN7Gl5l IlypdV2dX1McvuREj4WT6w13ljwe8kstLanyZxc2vHxiiEx+49D/wXG985pVNKRr ylJVWYremrtPz4/p4Ibcdy/9Cvh7V0GYtIIVCDzTCsaF8LVXzWQeqlcEiwG5G57D sC/4Ylwhp/U= =b7h/ -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Roy M. Silvernail says:
The thought occurs... the NSA doesn't seem particularly distressed that Clipper's LEAF can be spoofed and rendered unusable. Could this indicate that the LEAF isn't really necessary to retrieve the session key after all?
Anything is possible. I'd say that it is more likely that this indicates that the NSA is embarrassed by the entire episode, and that they are planning on releasing a fix to the EES. Each of these, seperately or together, is sufficient explanation. I don't think they'd deliberately weaken the system. Doing so would be too politically damaging to them in the long run. I believe they have honestly built the best system they can. That does not mean it is acceptable. Their honesty does not make the plan something that free people should allow to be imposed upon them. However, I believe that they are being reasonably honest. Even assuming honesty, the whole thing reeks. Perry
participants (2)
-
Perry E. Metzger -
roy@sendai.cybrspc.mn.org