RE: What was the quid pro quo for Wassenaar countries?

John Gilmore may be right, but remember folks that in Europe we have this thing the Greeks invented called democracy. One of the ideas of democracy is that decisions are not made in secret closed meetings. The interpretation of the US ambassador appears to be based on the assumption that the governmental proceedures of democratic countries are like those of his home country. In fact European governments cannot make law simply by telling the national police force to arrest folk who engage in particular behaviour. The system of checks and balances may be described in the US constitution but it is entrenched in the European polity. The UK does not have a national police force precisely to stop Hooverism. Even directives of the European Commission do not have legal force until the national parliaments enact legislation to implement the directive. One should also remember that the government of the Netherlands has agreed to control the sale and use of narcotics. If their efforts to control cryptography are as dilligent we have nothing to worry about. In addition under the single European act the entire country of Europe is one export zone for crypto control purposes. I fail to see that stopping Brits from exporting crypto to the US changes the equation a great deal. There once was an English king called Canute who attempted to demonstrate to his courtiers that he was fallible and could not order the tide to turn. Perhaps Clinton's courtiers need to learn that they suffer the same limmitation. Phill

I wonder what effect the Wassenaar politics have to non-member countries of that agreement and how much those other countries support these US crypto regulations? As I understand Wassenaar is mostly meant for export of dual-use goods, not so much internal use although that is somewhat regulated also. If that is the case, we still have many countries left producing strong cryptography which can export it pretty freely. That is a great export potential for those countries, only US used to be out of the world crypto software market, now that there are 22 other countries, it is just great news. Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania fortunately are not members of the Wassenaar agreement. And then we have places like most of Asia, Africa and South America. Jyri Kaljundi jk@stallion.ee AS Stallion Ltd http://www.stallion.ee/

Phillip Hallam-Baker wrote:
In addition under the single European act the entire country of Europe is one export zone for crypto control purposes.
Unfortunately, not yet. The European Commission has proposed amending the Dual-Use regulations to allow the free circulation of crypto products among member states, while extending controls to 'intangible' goods (i.e. Internet downloads). Until then an export license is required. Licenses are granted more readily and with fewer conditions (e.g. permitted end uses) for exports to other EU nations and Australia, Canada, Japan, New Zealand, Norway, Switzerland and the US. Amazing the minutiae you have to trawl when co-authoring a paper on crypto export controls ;) Ian.
participants (3)
-
Ian BROWN
-
Jyri Kaljundi
-
Phillip Hallam-Baker