Re: libsln.htm -- Is Libel a Crime?

At 01:14 AM 1/27/97 -0600, ichudov@algebra.com wrote:
I am not sure if you posted this information in response to my request to cite a statute that would prove that libel is a crime.
Me> Jim Choate wrote: Me> > Me> > Me> > Me> > Are you aware that attributing statements in print to a party when that Me> > party did not write them is a crime? Me> Me> cite the statute
These postings do not prove that libel is a crime. It is because libel is not a crime. Libel is a tort, and unlike with crime, the government cannot initiate a legal action against someone for libel. Only injured (libeled) individuals and not the government can sue in a libel case.
On the contrary, in some jurisdictions libel is indeed a crime. However, that doesn't mean that prosecutions happen anymore, but the laws are (in some places) still on the books. Jim Bell jimbell@pacifier.com

On Mon, 27 Jan 1997, jim bell wrote:
At 01:14 AM 1/27/97 -0600, ichudov@algebra.com wrote:
I am not sure if you posted this information in response to my request to cite a statute that would prove that libel is a crime.
Me> Jim Choate wrote: Me> > Me> > Me> > Me> > Are you aware that attributing statements in print to a party when that Me> > party did not write them is a crime? Me> Me> cite the statute
These postings do not prove that libel is a crime. It is because libel is not a crime. Libel is a tort, and unlike with crime, the government cannot initiate a legal action against someone for libel. Only injured (libeled) individuals and not the government can sue in a libel case.
On the contrary, in some jurisdictions libel is indeed a crime. However, that doesn't mean that prosecutions happen anymore, but the laws are (in some places) still on the books.
Jim Bell jimbell@pacifier.com
Jim, either you are full of shit or that Law is VERY unconstitutional. The first amendment prohibits any Criminal Laws from being made against libel. Being able to defame somebody is clearly within Freedom of speech. The only thing that is illegal in this Country is any speech proposing the killing of any President, and we can live with that. Nothing else is ever prohibited by the Criminal Law. Your only remedy for defamation of any kind is a civil Lawsuit. -DrG,Esq. esq@pgh.org by/aga.bot/telnet
participants (2)
-
aga
-
jim bell