W3 Self-Regulation?
[Where's Tipper when you need her? Answer:] FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contact: Ron Warris, President, Internet Filtering Systems, Inc. phone: 1-403-258-5804, email: warrisr@colt.t8000.com Web: www.tenagra.com/ifsi DEMOCRATIC WORLD-WIDE WEB SELF-REGULATION ANNOUNCED CALGARY, ALBERTA, CANADA -- October 30, 1995 -- Internet Filtering Systems, Inc. (IFSI) today announced Net Shepherd, the first product designed to democratically rate and filter World Wide Web sites and selectively supervise access. Net Shepherd is the first PICS-compliant rating and filtering solution. Under the auspices of The World Wide Web Consortium, PICS (Platform for Internet Content Selection) is a cross-industry working group whose goal is to facilitate the development of technologies to give users control over the kinds of material to which they and their children have access. According to Ron Warris, president of IFSI, "There are a number of companies offering filtering solutions. What is really needed is a rating solution. How do you go about reviewing and rating 8.5 million volatile documents on the Internet? Our approach will allow the people who surf the Internet to be the people who rate the Internet. With Net Shepherd, parents, educators and other concerned organizations will be able to voluntarily participate in the rating process. Mr. Warris continues, "Net Shepherd will also provide parents with the ability to selectively filter documents viewed by their children. Parents can choose from a variety of rating databases that represent the accumulated ratings from others who hold similar views and philosophies. Organizations that wish to create rating databases for their subscribers will also be able to use Net Shepherd. You'll be able to subscribe to the Good Housekeeping database or the Lutheran Church database or the ACLU database. Take your pick. "The Internet has always been self-regulating and special-interest-group oriented. Now the World Wide Web can be as well." IFSI's mission is to become the preferred and premier provider of Internet rating systems and services for individual consumers, concerned groups and associations, as well as other filter software developers. A World-Wide Web site currently contains basic information about IFSI, and will evolve over the coming weeks into an extensive resource for those interested in Internet content filtering. It is located at URL <http://www.tenagra.com/ifsi/>
From the Web page:
Internet Filtering Systems, Inc. is the developer of Net Shepherd, the first product designed to democratically rate and filter World Wide Web sites and selectively supervise access. The Internet has always been self-regulating and special-interest-group oriented. Now the World Wide Web can be as well. Net Shepherd is the first PICS-compliant rating and filtering solution. Under the auspices of The World Wide Web Consortium, PICS (Platform for Internet Content Selection) is a cross-industry working group whose goal is to facilitate the development of technologies to give users control over the kinds of material to which they and their children have access. Net Shepherd allows the people who surf the Internet to be the people who rate the Internet. With Net Shepherd, parents, educators and other concerned organizations will be able to voluntarily participate in the rating process. Net Shepherd will also provide parents with the ability to selectively filter documents viewed by their children. Parents can choose from a variety of rating databases that represent the accumulated ratings from others who hold similar views and philosophies. Organizations that wish to create rating databases for their subscribers will also be able to use Net Shepherd. IFSI's mission is to become the preferred and premier provider of Internet rating systems and services for individual consumers, concerned groups and associations, as well as other filter software developers. [cf. PICS (Platform for Internet Content Selection) at <http://www.w3.org/pub/WWW/PICS/>]
On Tue, 31 Oct 1995, Dave Del Torto wrote:
[Where's Tipper when you need her? Answer:]
Hey! Lay off the divine Ms. G! There's actually a big difference between labelling and censorship, though there's always the danger that once material has been labelled, Ralph Reed and his merry gang of cross burners will try to ban information bearing certain labels (the ol' gateway effect). Of course, if the labeling information isn't signed, the it's useless. Oh, and if people vote on labels, you really, really need secret voting protocols; this information can be very sensitive if it can be tied back to the voters. Simon p.s. What if instead of approving or banning drugs, the FDA instead just issued labels, and left the choices to the customer and his or her insurance agency... --- (defun modexpt (x y n) "computes (x^y) mod n" (cond ((= y 0) 1) ((= y 1) (mod x n)) ((evenp y) (mod (expt (modexpt x (/ y 2) n) 2) n)) (t (mod (* x (modexpt x (1- y) n)) n))))
DDT writes: # [Where's Tipper when you need her? Answer:] Simon writes:
Hey! Lay off the divine Ms. G!
Urgh. If I believed in a Hell, I'd expect the Parents Music Resource Center to have its HQ there.
There's actually a big difference between labelling and censorship,
Agreed, to the extent that providers are not required to label their products/services. But to my mind, the PICS software crosses the line between labelling and censorship. In particular, it is a tool with which parents will censor what their children encounter. Before Nathan Zook levels me, (hi :) let me elaborate. Such censorship seems to be inevitable/necessary given the relationship between parents and their children in our society. Parents are largely held liable for their childrens' actions, while children generally are not responsible for their own actions. I believe this arrangement is unfair, but until/unless it changes, parents must be given certain powers over those for whose actions they may be held liable. We've hashed over this stuff several times before, so I'm not sure how much sense it makes to reiterate it. -Futplex <futplex@pseudonym.com>
participants (3)
-
Dave Del Torto -
futplexï¼ pseudonym.com -
Simon Spero