-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- "LYLE, DAVID R." <uunet!pentagon-emh9.army.mil!lyled> writes:

Good question... what exactly is a "right"? To me, a right is something that cannot be removed from any citizen.

Then there are no rights. Can you name any "right" that has not been taken from some citizen, sometime, under some circumstances? The state can and will do with us, our bodies, and our minds, as it pleases. Not because it has permission, or because it's morally justified, but because it is willing to use force. Citizens who are unable to match the state with equal or greater force do not lose their claim to rights which have been ignored or trampled. I prefer to think of rights as "something that must not be removed from any citizen"; but even with that definition, we should be careful. Do we want to extend it to convicted criminals during the term of their punishments? What about to persons accused of (but not convicted of) crimes?

I would like to see privacy as a right.

I would, as well. I think it's important to assert that it *is* a right; perhaps not as well-defined in the Constitution as I'd like. The government may choose to pretend we do not have a right to privacy, but that doesn't change the fact that we have one. -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: 2.4 iQCVAgUBLW7IA33YhjZY3fMNAQFK6AP/YlHWd73wqVD+GPtdj7PU5pC1ZdvYYRhl zqLblWEi1f13qMh27+no+XgGIgX3r5Hdn9WuzD2i5X5E4txs6wNkVv8urZWeDPAB U89yzvEnr+XsMpd0e9L4OuuBU8Ri/Vxk58c18bis2lurzbYujX/+HSbo5afdCxpl qUD3U/op6QY= =SdCe -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- -- Greg Broiles ".. has bizarre Cyberanarchist theories relating greg@goldenbear.com to human punishment." -- L. Detweiler