Re: Voice Stress Analysis of Debates?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/81246/81246345345ef504ada2638b3961264c5b05ffc2" alt=""
Jim Bell queried the List about potential AP decision-support tools like voice-stress detectors which could identify truth-tellers among politicians and other possible candidates for Mr. Bell's much-debated proposal to cleanse the body politic. One anon C'punker responded with a fine terse summary of VS/PSE tech (along with the surprising news that VS/PSE chips are now available at $89.95 per.) Another, Sandy Sandfort, noted:
The original device was the PSE, the psychological stress evaluator. It was, as still is, sold by a company called Dektor. It is located in the DC area (Maryland?) and is run by a group of ex-spooks. It's been around for 25 years or so.
Dektor Counterintelligence is located in Savannah, Ga. The Dektor PSE was developed by Col. Allan Bell (USA, ret.) shortly after he retired from the Army, where -- towards the end of a long career which included, as I recall, a stint in charge of the MI detachment in West Berlin -- he had played "Q," the inventive spy-supply wizard, at the US Army military intelligence headquarters. Dektor's PSE came into some prominence after Col. Bell, then a civilian, showed up with his black box to assist Italian police during their huge investigation of the kidnapping of US Army General James Dozier by the Red Brigades in '82. The fact that Dozier was located and rescued by the Carabinieri commandos after five weeks in captivity -- while Prime Minister Aldo Moro had been murdered by the Red Brigades, eight weeks after his kidnapping in '78 -- led inevitably to stories, probably mythical, that Bell's PSE was a significant factor in the investigation. As Clarke or someone said, any technology sufficiently advanced will be considered magic -- and it is doubtless true that, for many Italians interviewed during the Drozier inquiry, the quiet presence of the diminutive American civilian, with his utterly mysterious "truth-detector," inspired fear and awe. The Legend that came out of Italy was doubtless a factor in Dektor's subsequent success selling the $5K PSE into the corporate and security market. (There was a period where corporate negotiations were sometimes held in a hotel chosen only just before the start of the talks, for fear that one party or the other might have pre-installed a PSE.) In the mid and late '80s, dozens, perhaps hundreds of PIs -- and maybe a few journalists -- were actually running around using tape recorders to interview people, then running back to their hotel rooms to spin the tape for their PSE. All of this was something of a giggle for Allan Bell, a Cold Warrior with a sense of humor who would _love_ this List. Bell offered (when asked) a much more modest description of the potential of the PSE. As I recall, Bell described the PSE as tool which could allow an investigator to identify, with reasonable certainty, the utterly innocent (lumped together, perhaps, with the utter psychotic; those who couldn't themselves separate truth from falsehood)... but which offered only limited utility in sorting the liars from others of various types who might experience stress or tension when faced with an interrogation or interview. The utterly innocent and the utterly psychotic both being relatively uncommon breeds (even among politicians and/or Libertarians,) the PSE never quite made it as a standard tool for criminal justice, or journalistic, inquiries. Bell set up what I always believed to be an elaborate practical joke on the Beltway Bandit Culture when, at the height of the PSE craze, he let Dektor's sales office in suburban D.C. -- Vienna, maybe? -- be used after-hours as the world headquarters/classroom/PR center for the short-lived Mensa University. (MU's president of which was a local PSE distributor, and very much a true believer.) The idea that the very bright might have to be very honest to matriculate intrigued me... but I'll admit I wasn't surprised when MU, quite honestly, collapsed into something of a laughingstock. Suerte, _Vin Vin McLellan +The Privacy Guild+ <vin@shore.net> 53 Nichols St., Chelsea, Ma. 02150 USA Tel: (617) 884-5548 <*><*><*><*><*><*><*><*><*>
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/050ab/050abcbb45bd3c84d28bba224ce50970f90116ae" alt=""
Vin McLellan wrote:
Jim Bell queried the List about potential AP decision-support tools like voice-stress detectors which could identify truth-tellers among politicians and other possible candidates for Mr. Bell's much-debated proposal to cleanse the body politic. One anon C'punker responded with a fine terse summary of VS/PSE tech (along with the surprising news that VS/PSE chips are now available at $89.95 per.) Another, Sandy Sandfort, noted:
[text stating in effect that VS/PSE is essentially useless deleted] The technical info is very much appreciated, by myself and subscribers as well, presumably. However, to suggest from the examples cited that this technology is near useless sounds more like yet another govt. smokescreen for their next-level technology, if you know what I mean, and I think you do.
participants (2)
-
Dale Thorn
-
vin@shore.net