:: Post-To: sci.crypt,alt.security.pgp Subject: PGP Questions I seem to remember reading somewhere that using PGP to encrypt a message for multiple recipients (in the same output file) somehow made cryptanalysis easier, but I don't seem to recall the rationale behind that concern. Can somebody comment on that. Also, concerning the PGP 2.3a/2.6/2.6ui controversy, is the only "problem" with 2.6 the fact that after 9/1/94 it will start reporting an incompatible version number that will make its output unreadable by older versions? If so, and if source code is available, why couldn't the date checking routine be located in the source code and simply commented out, then the whole thing recompiled? --
I seem to remember reading somewhere that using PGP to encrypt a message for multiple recipients (in the same output file) somehow made cryptanalysis easier, but I don't seem to recall the rationale behind that concern. Can somebody comment on that.
This is incorrect. There is a possible security problem with *pure* RSA, but PGP does not use pure RSA. When you encrypt to multiple recipients in PGP (and you can verify this by reading the code), you choose a random IDEA session key, and then you RSA-encrypt that key (with random-data padding) in each public key, changing the random padding with each encryption.
Also, concerning the PGP 2.3a/2.6/2.6ui controversy, is the only "problem" with 2.6 the fact that after 9/1/94 it will start reporting an incompatible version number that will make its output unreadable by older versions? If so, and if source code is available, why couldn't the date checking routine be located in the source code and simply commented out, then the whole thing recompiled?
No can do; this would validate the MIT license on the code. The change, about which you can obtain via anonymous ftp even if you are not in the US, is that the data-packet version number will change from '2' to '3' on september 1st, rendering older versions unable to read the data after 1 September. Hope this helps -derek Derek Atkins, SB '93 MIT EE, G MIT Media Laboratory Member, MIT Student Information Processing Board (SIPB) Home page: http://www.mit.edu:8001/people/warlord/home_page.html warlord@MIT.EDU PP-ASEL N1NWH PGP key available
participants (2)
-
Derek Atkins -
nobody@ds1.wu-wien.ac.at