A serious question of ethics
Ok, I'm in a bit of a quandry. While surfing the net last week, I happened across an address addached to a machine that belongs the the federal reserve. No big deal. I telnetted there on a lark, and entered 'guest' for the account. It dropped me into a shell. It didn't ask for a password. Intrigued, I did a little looking around. Nothing special, a CDRom and about 80 accounts. But(!!), /etc/passwd was there and available and not using shadows. No, I didn't snatch a copy. Quandry(ies) 1) Should I alert someone there about the obvious (and, IMHO serious) seciruty hole? or 2) Should I ignore it? 3) Should I take advantage of it (well, maybe not) ---------- I don't like to see systems so open, no matter who they belong too, and the fact that the governments (whether you like them or not) has one this open REALLY bothers me. But, I also wonder what kind of trouble I could get into. Technically, I violated something just by being there as I didn't have permission, and the fact I accessed the passwd file makes it even worse. If I report it, I could be in deep shit. I could mail to them via a remailer (like penet.fi, so that they could answer for more information if needed). That is a little securer and Julf is out of jurisdiction of the FBI hunting me down. Yes, I'm a little paranoid, but Uncle Sam likes to make examples out of white-collar hackers, and for me it was pure and dumb luck (like a jury would believe a 22 year-old computer geek isn't trying to gain illegal access). Any suggestions? Please? I consider this to be serious (most may not).
This seems like a textbook example of an ideal use of a remailer. What makes you hesitant to use that method? As you say, it's unlikely that the government would go to the extensive trouble of trying to bust you if you go through penet. The worst that could happen would be that they'd ignore the blowing whistle, but that'd be their problem. Note that there may be some way that they could figure out where you telnetted in from once you alert them to the security hole. -- | GOOD TIME FOR MOVIE - GOING ||| Mike McNally <m5@tivoli.com> | | TAKE TWA TO CAIRO. ||| Tivoli Systems, Austin, TX: | | (actual fortune cookie) ||| "Like A Little Bit of Semi-Heaven" |
3) Should I take advantage of it (well, maybe not)
How about offering your services to them as a security consultant.. grin. -- -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- - DrZaphod #Don't Come Any Closer Or I'll Encrypt! - - [AC/DC] / [DnA][HP] #Xcitement thru Technology and Creativity - - [drzaphod@brewmeister.xstablu.com] [MindPolice Censored This Bit] - - 50 19 1C F3 5F 34 53 B7 B9 BB 7A 40 37 67 09 5B - -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
participants (3)
-
drzaphod@brewmeister.xstablu.com -
m5@vail.tivoli.com -
nobody@pmantis.berkeley.edu