[OGSA-BES-WG] [ogsa-hpcp-wg] Revised version of BES draft specification

Mon Sep 4 22:05:14 CDT 2006

I'm concerned about the inclusion of the Appendix entitled "Container 
Model." This looks like useful material that should be published, but I 
don't believe it belongs in the BES specification.

At 06:30 PM 9/4/2006 -0500, Ian Foster wrote:
>I would like to claim the pen.
>
>Ian.
>
>At 02:56 PM 9/2/2006 -0600, Peter G. Lane wrote:
>>I'm done with my changes for the moment. The sections I was tasked to 
>>fill out were mostly done, so it was mostly just polish. I also did a lot 
>>of polishing to the operations, especially the schemas and WSDLs. I'd 
>>really appreciate it if people could look at this version before I put it 
>>up on the BES documents page. I want to make sure everybody's ok with the 
>>changes I made. Here is a general overview of what I did:
>>
>>- Changed all references to GetActivyStatus and GetActivitiesStatus (the 
>>document inconsistently had both) to GetActivityStatuses to be both self 
>>consistent and consistent with GetActivityDocuments (according to my 
>>dictionary, this is the correct plural of "status").
>>- Added myself to the authors list.
>>- Fixed some xsd:any element declarations in operation wrapper types.
>>- Removed "Type" suffix from all instance elements since they are not 
>>complexTypes.
>>- General clean up of the schema to be consistent and more readable.
>>- Removed all minOccurs="1" and maxOccurs="1" element attributes since 
>>these values are the default.
>>- Fixed the s12:Fault element declarations.
>>- Removed duplicate LocalResourceManagerType element from 
>>BasicResourceAttributesDocumentType (also exists in 
>>BESResourceAttributesDocumentType).
>>- Added fault element to the GetActivityDocuments response type
>>- Added explicit wsa:Action attributes to all input and output operation 
>>elements
>>- Updated the non-normative message examples
>>
>>I should note that the section numbers seem quite messed up. Somebody who 
>>has a better idea of where things are supposed to fit ought to make sure 
>>the numbers are ok. I would have assumed that Word would take care of 
>>this automatically, but I guess not.
>>
>>Peter
>>
>>
>>
>>Content-Type: application/x-pkcs7-signature; name="smime.p7s"
>>Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="smime.p7s"
>>Content-Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
>>
>>0€      *†H†÷
>>  €0€10  +0€     *†H†÷
>>  ‚P0‚¦0‚Ž Ñ0
>>         *†H†÷
>>0i10    ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate Authorities10U
>>DOEGrids CA 10
>>051111152456Z
>>061111152456Z0^10       ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,ddoegrids10
>>UPeople10UPeter G Lane 3642430‚"0
>>         *†H†÷
>>‚0‚‚»Ô”„äÓœÎ<¹ÖM 
>>‹Ù3¶é=ŸvU5âHÚñz®w7¼AhˆÂÃCñ;ŒU“d¥°%ólñŒß=hý„ŸÙmE[w"é!My”"c<ž2n‚Ž[dÿÞ¢fo®°5¶an
WAoØÁaé:Yšñbx=ÕÕ4ÝB©‡"L5”@`?ÛÐ©‡Nk2Åû—ü°ÿ·Þžø·Ÿ=D` 
>>É¦9æÑ³ùˆo¸ðÝ±Áä1éß¡Ô—F†®r8"[])}QJn>Õuï¯j^¸[Ñ½1¸•Ùç5èfãIÞoÝÎ?~”Ù‹|CUäÅÓº—;ù€Dy£c0a0 
>>`†H†øBà0Uÿð0U#0€ÊŽn¤8]BÔ1ÛÙ
>>]0U0lane at mcs.anl.gov0
>>         *†H†÷
>>‚|Âr
>>€¹vçÞW29z¾MbÎí³þÐãsaTÝ“rÁx¶ 
>>±<ð<]@Ígzñö#¬ûúÅÜ‘špxÜÝ¯f^b"À”cÖcX‰>¡ÞD"kPíòëSØ?ú¾=æ#Q¼×›æóh›Žé[
½¯´á0{¡i
>>õšâÀßó¨¾ŠÎ<â    <ü€‚W0ƒPdæ-±Ú-ÐŽâ
>>’Z}ÖÏŸ*%D6¸=iSpJ|µ0rÀi'LK×uOÌ/l ÆcÖƒFØ*í«ÁÐ`c
>>äÃ(¯¯â€`“G®{©æÐ>Ý¾_×÷4¯ÕÙ1÷ø ¦¢=ÿ9ÊJæðé¸¾ç0‚¦0‚Ž Ñ0
>>         *†H†÷
>>0i10    ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate Authorities10U
>>DOEGrids CA 10
>>051111152456Z
>>061111152456Z0^10       ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,ddoegrids10
>>UPeople10UPeter G Lane 3642430‚"0
>>         *†H†÷
>>‚0‚‚»Ô”„äÓœÎ<¹ÖM 
>>‹Ù3¶é=ŸvU5âHÚñz®w7¼AhˆÂÃCñ;ŒU“d¥°%ólñŒß=hý„ŸÙmE[w"é!My”"c<ž2n‚Ž[dÿÞ¢fo®°5¶an
WAoØÁaé:Yšñbx=ÕÕ4ÝB©‡"L5”@`?ÛÐ©‡Nk2Åû—ü°ÿ·Þžø·Ÿ=D` 
>>É¦9æÑ³ùˆo¸ðÝ±Áä1éß¡Ô—F†®r8"[])}QJn>Õuï¯j^¸[Ñ½1¸•Ùç5èfãIÞoÝÎ?~”Ù‹|CUäÅÓº—;ù€Dy£c0a0 
>>`†H†øBà0Uÿð0U#0€ÊŽn¤8]BÔ1ÛÙ
>>]0U0lane at mcs.anl.gov0
>>         *†H†÷
>>‚|Âr
>>€¹vçÞW29z¾MbÎí³þÐãsaTÝ“rÁx¶ 
>>±<ð<]@Ígzñö#¬ûúÅÜ‘špxÜÝ¯f^b"À”cÖcX‰>¡ÞD"kPíòëSØ?ú¾=æ#Q¼×›æóh›Žé[
½¯´á0{¡i
>>õšâÀßó¨¾ŠÎ<â    <ü€‚W0ƒPdæ-±Ú-ÐŽâ
>>’Z}ÖÏŸ*%D6¸=iSpJ|µ0rÀi'LK×uOÌ/l ÆcÖƒFØ*í«ÁÐ`c
>>äÃ(¯¯â€`“G®{©æÐ>Ý¾_×÷4¯ÕÙ1÷ø ¦¢=ÿ9ÊJæðé¸¾ç0‚ø0‚à 0
>>         *†H†÷
>>0u10    ’&‰“ò,dnet10    ’&‰“ò,dES10UESnet1 0UCertificate 
>>Authorities10UESnet Root CA 10
>>021205080000Z
>>080110080000Z0i10       ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate 
>>Authorities10U
>>DOEGrids CA 10‚"0
>>         *†H†÷
>>‚0‚‚´õÖ#a£Û>fµ¸o²šß-jmr¢‚Èq÷¼+.ËÛcâ,-ÿY"×d
>>n1ËË.kÙÉ—Ê—íºdÌ´ë`ß’™ 
>>IÔwÂŒáQ“HWKTo at lÖ²yþúq¥BÍ~!t.7‘«†8ôÜ5ö^Õ6ZÝí\ö·<5y9%šþgì²KœÅ!k´È€ÍÈ—_ú}!Á£Íç|%’wÓÖƒøcC¸v“ŒQ[7šÎrÎoÓ³µ•QýlW7¾‰ÌÅ‡lpk
]-ƒðÖ—ïcNßªæÑ-tö«Û°ÙZ®ƒÑo«<¦¤@ºJ{Mø]Ì{€êROÅÆ„QZ)ùcw¯?K£ž0›0 
>>`†H†øB‡0UÿÆ0UÊŽn¤8]BÔ1ÛÙ
>>]0U#0€¼]MH/ø5”Y«\‰K>Ñ²:ê0Uÿ0ÿ0%U0DOEGrids-CA-1 at doegrids.org0
>>         *†H†÷
>>‚*;b™>3p{)5V#ƒ+±¶(=vÎ”53Œ¡¿(B7â 
>>xQ{Â¤´`-#”gÝKøj1q.ãë˜8ÓÕ¶ÙðRa5Ô‰‚j½BFš¹ÃãÚ]=Â£3NQëji_gŒkÝE´´ªxýÊ^Í¸¿´þBkêÛÎ¹ñî¥@Çwè¨(v¶c¶‘JÊHÕdj‚Ý1rI¥ÿ¿£°ôÎ¥½ÐÝ 
>>u<iû²@x1îÀÑ¼¯†;DÚ‘ê ©Zµk;>Õz[½TÙï<xG
¸-*Õ#Å)eSÇ½º 
>>·±™ûþêß(ôüYy§@éÀGf¢åÿ.#A»1‚N0‚J0o0i10 ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 
>>0UCertificate Authorities10U
>>DOEGrids CA 1Ñ0 + ‚´0   *†H†÷
>>         1       *†H†÷
>>0       *†H†÷
>>         1
>>060902205636Z0# *†H†÷
>>         1<úÍNþR[9+£ì”$2³S0R    *†H†÷
>>         1E0C0 *†H†÷
>>0*†H†÷
>>€0
>>*†H†÷
>>@0+0
>>*†H†÷
>>(0~     +‚71q0o0i10     ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate 
>>Authorities10U
>>DOEGrids CA 1Ñ0€*†H†÷
>>         1q o0i10        ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate 
>> Authorities10U
>>DOEGrids CA 1Ñ0
>>         *†H†÷
>>‚>ÇÏSm°Šdò;±‡Øþ--‘Ü•|+œÃËfï{qFé,±Çz¾   »UÔ®JÛ¢ÇLˆßHöá 
>>ôDú+WÉƒ±¹Æ¹öV¬µó”ïý2˜ÓÎ´5ò4§š:¡²‘¸>bUVq ‡ý¼®©ZøÔ—èO|Œö«0‹—
>>:céAŒ·Ðú%3äj1‘ÍGÍq&ºÞc 
>>[ZÏÄ7§.FZY#É×¸’X^¤lNxèSâWÃàêqØÔäÐç€Ü*™aš€Ó’€êî/n3[m-Sí1p‡7-å„¢:<ŒüÎqµÅ9Ïž

>>xFù<Èïâ;^¿t|G.¦Þƒÿ|0ˆ_6
>>--
>>   ogsa-hpcp-wg mailing list
>>   ogsa-hpcp-wg at ogf.org
>>   http://www.ogf.org/mailman/listinfo/ogsa-hpcp-wg
>
>_______________________________________________________________
>Ian Foster -- Weblog: http://ianfoster.typepad.com
>Computation Institute: www.ci.uchicago.edu & www.ci.anl.gov
>Argonne: MCS/221, 9700 S. Cass Ave, Argonne, IL 60439
>Chicago: Rm 405, 5640 S. Ellis Ave, Chicago, IL 60637
>Tel: +1 630 252 4619 --- Globus Alliance: www.globus.org
>
>
>--
>   ogsa-hpcp-wg mailing list
>   ogsa-hpcp-wg at ogf.org
>   http://www.ogf.org/mailman/listinfo/ogsa-hpcp-wg

_______________________________________________________________
Ian Foster -- Weblog: http://ianfoster.typepad.com
Computation Institute: www.ci.uchicago.edu & www.ci.anl.gov
Argonne: MCS/221, 9700 S. Cass Ave, Argonne, IL 60439
Chicago: Rm 405, 5640 S. Ellis Ave, Chicago, IL 60637
Tel: +1 630 252 4619 --- Globus Alliance: www.globus.org

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://www.ogf.org/pipermail/ogsa-bes-wg/attachments/20060904/cd31ac46/attachment.html 