[occi-wg] OCCI Infrastructure 1.2 specification draft

[Boris Parak]

Hello Philippe,

thank you!

I will add these to our Trello board for discussion.

Cheers, Boris

On Fri, Dec 18, 2015 at 4:51 PM, Philippe Merle <philippe.merle at inria.fr> wrote:
> Hello,
>
> In the context of the OCCIware project (www.occiware.org), I implemented the
> OCCI Infrastructure 1.2 specification draft.
> Good news: OCCI Infrastructure 1.2 specification is implementable.
>
> During the implementation, I saw some typos into the specification draft but
> also some potential semantics issues:
>
> 1) Typos and minor semantics issues are corrected in
> https://github.com/occiware/occi-wg/commit/ce730cb74428d93a8bafb0b8b033b9d6e56c6428
>
> 2) In Figure 1 page 4:
>    - the type of occi.storage.size attribute is int when it is Float in
> Table 8 page 8.
>    - there is an occi.compute.speed attribute which is not present in Table
> 3 page 5.
>    - the occi.compute.share attribute of Table 3 page 5 is not present.
>    - *.state.message attributes are not present.
>
> 3) Figure 2 page 6 does not contain the new save action, i.e., a transition
> from active state to active state.
>
> 4) The default of attributes is not explicitly defined in Table 5, 8, 10,
> and 12.
>     Especially, the default value of *.state attributes must be defined, it
> could be defined to inactive.
>
> 5) In Figure 10 page 12, there are two occi.compute.speed attributes. But
> this attribute has been removed from Table 3.
>
> 6) At Line 262 and 272, it seems that the schema should contain
> 'infrastructure/' in order to be coherent with other schemas defined in this
> specification.
>
> 7) In Table 14, occi.compute.userdata must be immutable (not mutable) when
> reading the associated description ("It cannot be updated").
>
> 8) Page 17, the item "Removed occi.compute.speed attribute to Compute."
> should be added.
>
> Hoping this could help to improve in progress OCCI 1.2 specifications.
>
> Best regards
> Philippe Merle
> Inria
>