[Nml-wg] Simple example #1

[Roman Łapacz]

W dniu 2012-07-20 15:31, Freek Dijkstra pisze:
> On 19-07-2012 16:02, Roman Łapacz wrote:
>> An example updated. Available in the repo
>> (nml-examples/201207-groups-and-labels). Any comments are welcome.
> Seems good, only a few small issues caught my eye:
>
>>          <nml:Port idRef="urn:ogf:network:domainx.net:2012:A:port_ge-0.2.9-out"/>
> [...]
>>      <nml:PortGroup id="urn:ogf:network:domainx.net:2012:A:port_ge-0.2.9-out">
> The all nml:Port for this object should be a nml:PortGroup.

I thought that Port inside Relation and BidirectionalPort can represent 
referenced PortGroup. I can change that.

>
> At least, I presume you want to model the VLANs over these links, not
> necessarily the underling Ethernet layer?
>
> Some holds for
> <nml:Link id="urn:ogf:network:domainx.net:2012:domainy-domainx">
> (I think you want to model this as a LinkGroup).
>
> I briefly wondered if the following is allowed, if you make this change,
> but I don't see why not:
>
>>      <nml:BidirectionalLink id="urn:ogf:network:domainx.net:2012:domainx-domainy-domainx">
>>        <nml:name>Link between domain x and domain y</nml:name>
>>        <nml:LinkGroup idRef="urn:ogf:network:domainx.net:2012:domainx-domainy"/>
>>        <nml:LinkGroup idRef="urn:ogf:network:domainx.net:2012:domainy-domainx"/>
>>      </nml:Link>

Seems reasonable because there's a range on vlans in this case.

>
> Note that in your example, there is no cross connect between a VLAN in
> port ge-1/0/9 and VLAN 1501 of port ge-1/0/8. Not really suprising,
> since you have non-matching VLANS, but I wondered if this was on purpose.

Yes. I didn't want to do the cross in this example. But it can be 
presented in an other one (good candidate; I think the more examples 
presenting various setups the better).


The file updated.

Roman

>
>
> Nice use of isAlias by the way.
>
>
>> (btw. I've done few minor updates in the RNC schema as well)
> Thanks. I still suck at reading RNC, so I'm going to read this in detail
> after two more iterations of the draft document.
>
> Freek