[GRIDRPC-WG] Final call for comments

[Andre Merzky]

Hi Yusuke, 

some comments:

  3.7.1   Notes for Results 
  The error code, GRPC_NOT_INITIALIZED, is not defined in
  the error reporting functions, in Section 4.7 of GFD-R.52.
  When the functions are called before grpc_initialize() is
  called, however, some GridRPC implementations might return
  GRPC_NOT_INITIALIZED.

  -> is that something which should be fixed in the spec
  then?  I.e are the implementations which return
  GRPC_NOT_INITIALIZED here otherwise non-compliant?


  "The differences are not beyond of this kind of learning
  but understandable."

  -> I am not sure if that sentence makes sense.


  "In addition, three behaviors are not defined in the
  specification."

  ->  I think we discussed about taht in Chapel Hill.  I'd
  vote for writing:

  "In addition, three behaviors are intentionally left
  unspecified in the specification."

  That should make clear that this does not point to a
  failure in the interoperab. testing, but is the expected
  result.


A minor thing about layout: I alsways think that block
justified documents look much prettier than left justified
ones.  That may be my personal preference, and come from the
fact that block justified is the default in latex, whereas
left justified is the default in Word.  Anyway, wanted to
mention it... :-)

Otherwise the doc looks good to me.

Cheers, Andre.


Quoting [Yusuke Tanimura] (Feb 18 2007):
> From: Yusuke Tanimura <yusuke.tanimura at aist.go.jp>
> To: gridrpc-wg at ogf.org
> Subject: [GRIDRPC-WG] Final call for comments
> 
> Dear all,
> 
> I modified several parts of the GridRPC interoperability test document
> according to ESTI comments and discussions at OGF19.
> Please read through the attachment and send any comments to the
> mailing list within a week.
> 
> If there is no further comments, the document will be resubmitted to
> the editor.
> 
> Thanks for your cooperation.
> 
> -----------------------------------------------------
> Yusuke Tanimura <yusuke.tanimura at aist.go.jp>
> Grid Technology Research Center, National Institute of AIST
> 1-1-1 Umezono, Tsukuba Central 2
> Tsukuba City 305-8568, Japan
> TEL: +81-29-862-6703  / FAX: +81-29-862-6601
-- 
"So much time, so little to do..."  -- Garfield