[GRIDCPR-WG] CPR documents...

[Nathan Stone]

Hi Andre, et al.

	What was the reason for stripping out all of the transaction labels in 
Figure 1?  The text still refers to them heavily, but with lots of 
"FIXME"s.  I fail to see the logic in removing all the visual content 
and then asking someone else to "FIX" the verbal content.

	Should we not put the visual labels /back/ into the figure?

Please advise,
	Nathan.

Andre Merzky wrote:
> ----------------------------------------------------
>           Sorry for crossposting.
>     Followups should go to the GridCPR list only.
> ----------------------------------------------------
> 
> Hi all, 
> 
> the GridCPR WG had two documents in the GGF/OGF document
> pipeline (informational).  Both are stuck in the pipeline,
> after already passing public comment, mostly for the reason
> that people left the CPR WG, and nobody addressed the
> comments, and finalized the documents.
> 
> As the SAGA RG/WG use the documents to motivate the CPR API
> package in SAGA, some people felt motivated to pick up the
> CPR docs, and push them through the last stages of the
> pipeline.
> 
> Now, for that purpose we re-created the documents, put them
> into the SAGA CVS, and started to address the public
> comments.  However, as the documents are somewhat old by
> now, it seems appropriate to reconsider a number of elements
> in respect to new developments in OGF (e.g. data manegement
> and security can be more explicetly marked as external, as
> can the API).
> 
> We would appreciate if people from both groups could read
> the documents once more, and provide in-group feedback.  In
> particular the architecture document would benefit from
> that.
> 
> The documents are attached.  Please let us know if you want
> write access to CVS directly.  The URLs for the public
> comments are:
> 
>   http://forge.ogf.org/short/EDITOR/doc-cpr-uc
>   http://forge.ogf.org/short/EDITOR/doc-cpr-arch
> 
> Cheers, Andre.
> 
> 
> 
> 
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
> --
>   gridcpr-wg mailing list
>   gridcpr-wg at ogf.org
>   http://www.ogf.org/mailman/listinfo/gridcpr-wg

-- 
  +-----------------------------+----------------------------------+
  | Nathan T.B. Stone, Ph.D.    | Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center |
  | Advanced Systems Group      | 300 S. Craig St.                 |
  +-----------------------------+ Pittsburgh, PA 15213             |
  | mailto:stone at psc.edu        | phone: 412-268-4367              |
  | http://www.psc.edu/~nstone/ | fax:   412-268-5832              |
  +-----------------------------+----------------------------------+