[drmaa-wg] DRMAA-WG May 3, 2005 meeting minutes
Peter Troeger
peter.troeger at hpi.uni-potsdam.de
Tue May 3 12:37:42 CDT 2005
>A. Meeting secretary for this meeting?
>
>
Peter.
>B. Acceptance of the Apr 19, 2005 meeting minutes
>
>
Accepted.
>C. Admin
> - status of the existing trackers
> - remaining trackers - see Peter's mail
>
>
* Placeholder issue (#805) : Hrabri will ask Bill for PBS semantics
* Discussion about error code proposals in 1177 (closely related to
1178, 1180, 1183, 1184) :
* Proposal to add DRMAA_ERRNO_DRM_COMMUNICATION_FAILURE to all functions
* Use case: SGE DRMAA implementation uses sockets for communication
with DRMS, so comm failure may occur in any case
* -> Acceptance of the idea suggested : an implementation is not
enforced to make us of it, but there are cases ('remote DRMAA')
where this is needed
* Proposal to add DRMAA_ERRNO_NO_ACTIVE_SESSION to all manipulation
functions for job templates
* Leads to discussion about job template reuse between sessions
* Actual SGE Java-DRMAA implementation deletes all job templates on
session closing (otherwise memory leak with underlying C-DRMAA)
* problem of different attribute semantics in different sessions ->
agreement that this can mostly only be checked on job submission
time -> would open possibility for job template reuse
* Counter-argument: Session is responsible for memory management,
job template reuse may be difficult to implement
* Discussion result: Realizability of job template reuse depends on
environmental conditions of the specific language, no decision
possible for language-independent spec
* -> Acceptance of the idea suggested : an implementation might have
a need to express this error condition, in case it does not allow
job template reuse
* Proposal to add DRMAA_ERRNO_AUTH_FAILURE to all functions
* original DRMAA idea was that authentication happens on
initialization time
* -> Rejection of the idea suggested (e.g. for 1177, 1183, 1148, 1180)
* Proposal to start one mail thread per error code, in order to
reach final decisions
More information about the drmaa-wg
mailing list