Anti War: Thread

grarpamp grarpamp at
Thu May 26 23:30:34 PDT 2022

No Way Out But War

Permanent war has cannibalized the country. It has created a social,
political, and economic morass. Each new military debacle is another
nail in the coffin of Pax Americana...

Original Illustration by Mr. Fish — “No Guts No Glory”

The United States, as the near unanimous vote to provide nearly $40
billion in aid to Ukraine illustrates, is trapped in the death spiral
of unchecked militarism. No high speed trains. No universal health
care. No viable Covid relief program. No respite from 8.3 percent
inflation. No infrastructure programs to repair decaying roads and
bridges, which require $41.8 billion to fix the 43,586 structurally
deficient bridges, on average 68 years old. No forgiveness of $1.7
trillion in student debt. No addressing income inequality. No program
to feed the 17 million children who go to bed each night hungry. No
rational gun control or curbing of the epidemic of nihilistic violence
and mass shootings. No help for the 100,000 Americans who die each
year of drug overdoses. No minimum wage of $15 an hour to counter 44
years of wage stagnation. No respite from gas prices that are
projected to hit $6 a gallon.

The permanent war economy, implanted since the end of World War II,
has destroyed the private economy, bankrupted the nation, and
squandered trillions of dollars of taxpayer money. The monopolization
of capital by the military has driven the US debt to $30 trillion, $ 6
trillion more than the US GDP of $ 24 trillion. Servicing this debt
costs $300 billion a year. We spent more on the military, $ 813
billion for fiscal year 2023, than the next nine countries, including
China and Russia, combined.

We are paying a heavy social, political, and economic cost for our
militarism. Washington watches passively as the U.S. rots, morally,
politically, economically, and physically, while China, Russia, Saudi
Arabia, India, and other countries extract themselves from the tyranny
of the U.S. dollar and the international Society for Worldwide
Interbank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT), a messaging network
banks and other financial institutions use to send and receive
information, such as money transfer instructions. Once the U.S. dollar
is no longer the world’s reserve currency, once there is an
alternative to SWIFT, it will precipitate an internal economic
collapse. It will force the immediate contraction of the U.S. empire
shuttering most of its nearly 800 overseas military installations. It
will signal the death of Pax Americana.

Democrat or Republican. It does not matter. War is the raison d’état
of the state. Extravagant military expenditures are justified in the
name of “national security.” The nearly $40 billion allocated for
Ukraine, most of it going into the hands of weapons manufacturers such
as Raytheon Technologies, General Dynamics, Northrop Grumman, BAE
Systems, Lockheed Martin, and Boeing, is only the beginning. Military
strategists, who say the war will be long and protracted, are talking
about infusions of $4 or $5 billion in military aid a month to
Ukraine. We face existential threats. But these do not count. The
proposed budget for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) in fiscal year 2023 is $10.675 billion. The proposed budget for
the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is $11.881 billion. Ukraine
alone gets more than double that amount. Pandemics and the climate
emergency are afterthoughts. War is all that matters. This is a recipe
for collective suicide.

There were three restraints to the avarice and bloodlust of the
permanent war economy that no longer exist.

    The first was the old liberal wing of the Democratic Party, led by
politicians such as Senator George McGovern, Senator Eugene McCarthy,
and Senator J. William Fulbright, who wrote The Pentagon Propaganda
Machine. The self-identified progressives, a pitiful minority, in
Congress today, from Barbara Lee, who was the single vote in the House
and the Senate opposing a broad, open-ended authorization allowing the
president to wage war in Afghanistan or anywhere else, to Ilhan Omar
now dutifully line up to fund the latest proxy war.

    The second restraint was an independent media and academia,
including journalists such as I.F Stone and Neil Sheehan along with
scholars such as Seymour Melman, author of The Permanent War Economy
and Pentagon Capitalism: The Political Economy of War.

    Third, and perhaps most important, was an organized anti-war
movement, led by religious leaders such as Dorothy Day, Martin Luther
King Jr. and Phil and Dan Berrigan as well as groups such as Students
for a Democratic Society (SDS). They understood that unchecked
militarism was a fatal disease.

None of these opposition forces, which did not reverse the permanent
war economy but curbed its excesses, now exist. The two ruling parties
have been bought by corporations, especially military contractors. The
press is anemic and obsequious to the war industry. Propagandists for
permanent war, largely from right-wing think tanks lavishly funded by
the war industry, along with former military and intelligence
officials, are exclusively quoted or interviewed as military experts.
NBC’s “Meet the Press” aired a segment May 13 where officials from
Center for a New American Security (CNAS) simulated what a war with
China over Taiwan might look like. The co-founder of CNAS, Michèle
Flournoy, who appeared in the “Meet the Press” war games segment and
was considered by Biden to run the Pentagon, wrote in 2020 in Foreign
Affairs that the U.S. needs to develop “the capability to credibly
threaten to sink all of China’s military vessels, submarines and
merchant ships in the South China Sea within 72 hours.”

The handful of anti-militarists and critics of empire from the left,
such as Noam Chomsky, and the right, such as Ron Paul, have been
declared persona non grata by a compliant media. The liberal class has
retreated into boutique activism where issues of class, capitalism and
militarism are jettisoned for “cancel culture,” multiculturalism and
identity politics. Liberals are cheerleading the war in Ukraine. At
least the inception of the war with Iraq saw them join significant
street protests. Ukraine is embraced as the latest crusade for freedom
and democracy against the new Hitler. There is little hope, I fear, of
rolling back or restraining the disasters being orchestrated on a
national and global level.  The neoconservatives and liberal
interventionists chant in unison for war. Biden has appointed these
war mongers, whose attitude to nuclear war is terrifyingly cavalier,
to run the Pentagon, the National Security Council, and the State

Since all we do is war, all proposed solutions are military. This
military adventurism accelerates the decline, as the defeat in Vietnam
and the squandering of $8 trillion in the futile wars in the Middle
East illustrate. War and sanctions, it is believed, will cripple
Russia, rich in gas and natural resources. War, or the threat of war,
will curb the growing economic and military clout of China.

These are demented and dangerous fantasies, perpetrated by a ruling
class that has severed itself from reality. No longer able to salvage
their own society and economy, they seek to destroy those of their
global competitors, especially Russia and China. Once the militarists
cripple Russia, the plan goes, they will focus military aggression on
the Indo-Pacific, dominating what Hillary Clinton as secretary of
state, referring to the Pacific, called “the American Sea.”

You cannot talk about war without talking about markets. The U.S.,
whose growth rate has fallen to below 2 percent, while China’s growth
rate is 8.1 percent, has turned to military aggression to bolster its
sagging economy. If the U.S. can sever Russian gas supplies to Europe,
it will force Europeans to buy from the United States. U.S. firms, at
the same time, would be happy to replace the Chinese Communist Party,
even if they must do it through the threat of war, to open unfettered
access to Chinese markets. War, if it did break out with China, would
devastate the Chinese, American, and global economies, destroying free
trade between countries as in World War I. But that doesn’t mean it
won’t happen.

Washington is desperately trying to build military and economic
alliances to ward off a rising China, whose economy is expected by
2028 to overtake that of the United States, according to the UK’s
Centre for Economics and Business Research (CEBR). The White House has
said Biden’s current visit to Asia is about sending a “powerful
message” to Beijing and others about what the world could look like if
democracies “stand together to shape the rules of the road.” The Biden
administration has invited South Korea and Japan to attend the NATO
summit in Madrid.

But fewer and fewer nations, even among European allies, are willing
to be dominated by the United States. Washington’s veneer of democracy
and supposed respect for human rights and civil liberties is so badly
tarnished as to be irrecoverable. Its economic decline, with China’s
manufacturing 70 percent higher than that of the U.S., is
irreversible. War is a desperate Hail Mary, one employed by dying
empires throughout history with catastrophic consequences. “It was the
rise of Athens and the fear that this instilled in Sparta that made
war inevitable,” Thucydides noted in the History of the Peloponnesian

A key component to the sustenance of the permanent war state was the
creation of the All-Volunteer Force. Without conscripts, the burden of
fighting wars falls to the poor, the working class, and military
families. This All-Volunteer Force allows the children of the middle
class, who led the Vietnam anti-war movement, to avoid service. It
protects the military from internal revolts, carried out by troops
during the Vietnam War, which jeopardized the cohesion of the armed

The All-Volunteer Force, by limiting the pool of available troops,
also makes the global ambitions of the militarists impossible.
Desperate to maintain or increase troop levels in Iraq and
Afghanistan, the military instituted the stop-loss policy that
arbitrarily extended active-duty contracts. Its slang term was the
backdoor draft. The effort to bolster the number of troops by hiring
private military contractors, as well, had a negligible effect.
Increased troop levels would not have won the wars in Iraq and
Afghanistan but the tiny percentage of those willing to serve in the
military (only 7 percent of the U.S. population are veterans) is an
unacknowledged Achilles heel for the militarists.

    “As a consequence, the problem of too much war and too few
soldiers eludes serious scrutiny,” writes historian and retired Army
Colonel Andrew Bacevich in After the Apocalypse: America’s Role in a
World Transformed.

    “Expectations of technology bridging that gap provide an excuse to
avoid asking the most fundamental questions: Does the United States
possess the military wherewithal to oblige adversaries to endorse its
claim of being history’s indispensable nation? And if the answer is
no, as the post-9/11 wars in Afghanistan and Iraq suggest, wouldn’t it
make sense for Washington to temper its ambitions accordingly?”

This question, as Bacevich points out, is “anathema.” The military
strategists work from the supposition that the coming wars won’t look
anything like past wars. They invest in imaginary theories of future
wars that ignore the lessons of the past, ensuring more fiascos.

The political class is as self-deluded as the generals. It refuses to
accept the emergence of a multi-polar world and the palpable decline
of American power. It speaks in the outdated language of American
exceptionalism and triumphalism, believing it has the right to impose
its will as the leader of the “free world.” In his 1992 Defense
Planning Guidance memorandum, U.S. Under Secretary of Defense Paul
Wolfowitz argued that the U.S. must ensure no rival superpower again
arises. The U.S. should project its military strength to dominate a
unipolar world in perpetuity. On February 19, 1998, on NBC’s “Today
Show”, Secretary of State Madeleine Albright gave the Democratic
version of this doctrine of unipolarity. “If we have to use force it
is because we are Americans; we are the indispensable nation,” she
said. “We stand tall, and we see further than other countries into the

This demented vision of unrivaled U.S. global supremacy, not to
mention unrivaled goodness and virtue, blinds the establishment
Republicans and Democrats. The military strikes they casually used to
assert the doctrine of unipolarity, especially in the Middle East,
swiftly spawned jihadist terror and prolonged warfare. None of them
saw it coming until the hijacked jets slammed into the World Trade
Center twin towers. That they cling to this absurd hallucination is
the triumph of hope over experience.

There is a deep loathing among the public for these elitist Ivy League
architects of American imperialism. Imperialism was tolerated when it
was able to project power abroad and produce rising living standards
at home. It was tolerated when it restrained itself to covert
interventions in countries such as Iran, Guatemala, and Indonesia. It
went off the rails in Vietnam. The military defeats that followed
accompanied a steady decline in living standards, wage stagnation, a
crumbling infrastructure and eventually a series of economic policies
and trade deals, orchestrated by the same ruling class, which
deindustrialized and impoverished the country.

The establishment oligarchs, now united in the Democratic Party,
distrust Donald Trump. He commits the heresy of questioning the
sanctity of the American empire. Trump derided the invasion of Iraq as
a “big, fat mistake.” He promised “to keep us out of endless war.”
Trump was repeatedly questioned about his relationship with Vladimir
Putin. Putin was “a killer,” one interviewer told him. “There are a
lot of killers,” Trump retorted. “You think our country’s so
innocent?” Trump dared to speak a truth that was to be forever
unspoken, the militarists had sold out the American people.

Noam Chomsky took some heat for pointing out, correctly, that Trump is
the “one statesman” who has laid out a “sensible” proposition to
resolve the Russia-Ukraine crisis. The proposed solution included
“facilitating negotiations instead of undermining them and moving
toward establishing some kind of accommodation in Europe…in which
there are no military alliances but just mutual accommodation.”

Trump is too unfocused and mercurial to offer serious policy
solutions. He did set a timetable to withdraw from Afghanistan, but he
also ratcheted up the economic war against Venezuela and reinstituted
crushing sanctions against Cuba and Iran, which the Obama
administration had ended. He increased the military budget. He
apparently flirted with carrying out a missile strike on Mexico to
“destroy the drug labs.” But he acknowledges a distaste for imperial
mismanagement that resonates with the public, one that has every right
to loath the smug mandarins that plunge us into one war after another.
Trump lies like he breathes. But so do they.

The 57 Republicans who refused to support the $40 billion aid package
to Ukraine, along with many of the 19 bills that included an earlier
$13.6 billion in aid for Ukraine, come out of the kooky conspiratorial
world of Trump. They, like Trump, repeat this heresy. They too are
attacked and censored. But the longer Biden and the ruling class
continue to pour resources into war at our expense, the more these
proto fascists, already set to wipe out Democratic gains in the House
and the Senate this fall, will be ascendant. Marjorie Taylor Greene,
during the debate on the aid package to Ukraine, which most members
were not given time to closely examine, said:

    “$40 billion dollars but there’s no baby formula for American
mothers and babies.”

    “An unknown amount of money to the CIA and Ukraine supplemental
bill but there’s no formula for American babies,” she added.

    “Stop funding regime change and money laundering scams. A US
politician covers up their crimes in countries like Ukraine.”

Democrat Jamie Raskin immediately attacked Greene for parroting the
propaganda of Russian president Vladimir Putin.

Greene, like Trump, spoke a truth that resonates with a beleaguered
public. The opposition to permanent war should have come from the tiny
progressive wing of the Democratic Party, which unfortunately sold out
to the craven Democratic Party leadership to save their political
careers. Greene is demented, but Raskin and the Democrats peddle their
own brand of lunacy. We are going to pay a very steep price for this

More information about the cypherpunks mailing list