MacArthur: “Rule 1, on page 1 of the book of war, is: ‘Do not march on Moscow'” - [PEACE]
Zenaan Harkness
zen at freedbms.net
Wed Jan 16 20:13:10 PST 2019
A reasonable mashup comparison of Napoleon's march on Moscow
(courtesy the memoirs of Caulaincourt) and today's USA "Empire of Mug
Values"^BMuh Values, & with a link to "the famous graph" which is
new to some (speaking for a friend ;)
https://proxy.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=http://iaincarstairs.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/napoleons-march-01-red.jpg
** The West and Russia: C’est Toujours La même Chose
https://patrickarmstrong.ca/2019/01/05/cest-toujours-la-meme-chose/?mc_cid=f4ba3dc39b
… His account begins with a long conversation with Napoleon. Just
before he left St Petersburg, Alexander called him in for what was,
unmistakeably, a message and warning to be passed on. De
Caulaincourt really tries hard – but unsuccessfully – to make
Napoleon get the point. He tells him that Alexander said he had
learned something from the Spanish resistance to France and that
was that Napoleon’s other opponents had given up too early; they
should have kept fighting. Napoleon is unimpressed: his generals in
Spain are incompetent and and his brother (to whom he had given the
Spanish throne) is an idiot; he sees no larger lessons and believes
that Spain is not important in the great scheme. De Caulaincourt
reiterates that Alexander kept returning to that point, giving
other illustrations of giving up too soon and emphasised that, if
Napoleon invaded, he would persevere: he would keep fighting from
Kamchatka if need be; Russia was very large and the weather very
severe. One good battle and they’ll give up insists Napoleon.
Napoleon then mentions how angry the Poles are getting with Russia.
De Caulaincourt retorts that the Poles he knows, while they would
certainly prefer a free and independent Poland, have learned that
living under Russia is not as bad as they thought it would be and
that real freedom might cost more than it would be worth. De
Caulaincourt then, no doubt repeating what Alexander has told him,
describes the compromise that would settle the problems between him
and Russia; but Napoleon’s not interested. After five hours of
this, Napoleon dismisses him but de Caulaincourt asks leave to say
one more thing: if you are thinking of invading (now de
Caulaincourt realises that he’s set on it) please think of France’s
best interests. Oh says Napoleon, now you’re talking like a
Russian.
…
More information about the cypherpunks
mailing list