Camera grid to log number plates

[Eugen Leitl]

http://newsvote.bbc.co.uk/mpapps/pagetools/print/news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/whos_watching_you/8064333.stm 

Camera grid to log number plates

By Richard Bilton

Special correspondent, BBC News

A national network of cameras and computers automatically logging car number
plates will be in place within months, the BBC has learned.

Thousands of Automatic Number Plate Recognition cameras are already operating
on Britain's roads.

Police forces across England, Wales and Scotland will soon be able to share
the information on one central computer.

Officers say it is a useful tool in fighting crime, but critics say the
network is secretive and unregulated.

Kent's Chief Constable, Michael Fuller, commented: "We've seen an increase of
some 40% of arrests since we've been using this technology.

"I'm very confident that we're using it properly and responsibly, and that
innocent people have nothing to fear from the way we use it."

A number of local councils are signing up their Closed Circuit Television
(CCTV) systems to the ANPR network. As long as the cameras are technically
good enough, they can be adapted to take the software.

In towns such as Bradford, Portsmouth and Luton that means greater coverage
for the police and more journeys captured and recorded.

John Dean, who is co-ordinating the ANPR network for the Association of Chief
Police Officers, said: "It's the finest intelligence-led policing tool we've
got.

"It covers so many different areas from crime reduction, crime detection to
road safety and everything in between."

Marked car

But not everyone thinks it is such a good thing.

John Catt found himself on the wrong side of the ANPR system. He regularly
attends anti-war demonstrations outside a factory in Brighton, his home town.

It was at one of these protests that Sussex police put a "marker" on his car.
That meant he was added to a "hotlist".

This is a system meant for criminals but John Catt has not been convicted of
anything and on a trip to London, the pensioner found himself pulled over by
an anti-terror unit.

"I was threatened under the Terrorist Act. I had to answer every question
they put to me, and if there were any questions I would refuse to answer, I
would be arrested. I thought to myself, what kind of world are we living in?"

Sussex police would not talk about the case.

The police say they do not know how many cameras there are in total, and they
say that for operational reasons they will not say where the fixed cameras
are positioned.

'Limited resources'

Information Commissioner Richard Thomas, whose job it is to protect personal
data, has concerns about the lack of regulation.

He said: "There's very little monitoring. I mean, my office has very limited
powers.

"We have very limited resources. We are not actively monitoring that area.
You're right to ask the question. No one's checking it at the moment"

The BBC TV series Who's Watching You? asked the Home Secretary, Jacqui Smith,
to comment on the Commissioner's views.

"It's something that we will look at further legislation about where
necessary," she said.

"I don't think we should lose sight of the very considerable benefits that
this technology also brings us, brings law enforcement."

Recent research by Huddersfield University found that the public seemed to
share that view. The study took place in Leeds as the ANPR system was being
introduced. The vast majority supported the cameras if they caught law
breakers, with only a few mentioning concerns about police surveillance.

The police themselves say they have nothing to hide and would welcome the
introduction of a regulatory code. But that seems some way off - and for now
this secretive system continues to watch us and continues to grow.