[technoliberation] Does Technoliberation have $24.95 to spend?

Justice De Thezier dethezier at hotmail.com
Mon Dec 26 07:59:40 PST 2005

>From http://alternet.org/story/29899/ :

The Best $24.95 MoveOn Ever Spent

By Micah L. Sifry, Personal Democracy Forum.
Posted December 24, 2005.

MoveOn's popular Flickr photo-sharing account shows how political
causes can engage people who are already socializing online.

If you're a typical fan of Flickr, the community photo-sharing site
that was recently bought by Yahoo, then you are undoubtedly already
familiar with Flickr's tagging system, which allows anyone who
uploads a photo to the site to add his or her own topical notations
to each photo. One of the site's best features is its main tags
page, where not only can you see some of the hottest tags in the
last few days (snowday and lennon being two example), but you can
also browse the site's most popular tags, which are arranged in
a "tag cloud" that shows each word (beach, birthday, cameraphone,
japan, me, vacation) and indicates its relative popularity by the
word's type size. Click on any tag and you're taken to a stream of
recent public photos with that tag.

But if by some chance you stumble onto one Flickr member's home
page, you'll discover a very odd-seeming list of tags in its cloud,
led by antiroverally, approved, candlelight, cindysheehan,
faceamerica, great, memberadded, mothers, photopetition, and vigil.

Welcome to the public Flickr account of MoveOn.org. With little
notice, the giant liberal advocacy group has dipped its toes into
the social networking slipstream, and so far it's quite enthralled
with the experiment.

Says MoveOn CTO Patrick Michael Kane, of the firm We Also Walk
Dogs, "Flickr has got to be the best $24.95 we've ever spent. We've
been able to review, organize and make available over 11,000 photos
to MoveOn (and Flickr!) members." In November alone, he says, the
group uploaded over a gigabyte of photos, and it has been able to
make photos from campaigns available in real time.

As far as I know, this is the first major use of Flickr by a
political campaign. Individuals have attempted to make use of the
site's free service and simple tagging feature to express a
collective point; for example the writer Rob Walker has spawned a
haunting series of photos that are all tagged Mlkblvd to bring
together photos of the many streets and boulevards across America
that have been named for Martin Luther King Jr., quietly
illustrating how far the country has to go before King's vision of
equality is realized. People have also spontaneously tagged their
photos of political events, there are plenty of provocative photos
that people have tagged "politics," and Flickr does support the
formation of groups around pictorial themes. But so far these
efforts are very scattered.

Sharing the work

MoveOn came to Flickr in large degree because its own internal
system for receiving members' photos of events, reviewing them and
posting them wasn't very functional. MoveOn has long used photos to
show its members that they are part of something much larger; after
the group helped spawn thousands of grass-roots candlelight vigils
across America just before the invasion of Iraq, its staff put
together an amazing page of photos showing how the events went
worldwide. But managing the flood of photos that come in around each
MoveOn event, Kane says, was complicated.

"Finding the best photos was difficult and the sheer number of
photos meant that we often had to take photos offline to save disk
space," he explains. "The system was also very campaign-oriented --
it provided ways to get at photos in the context of a certain
campaign, but not a great way to look at all the photos that MoveOn
members had taken over time."

Meanwhile, Kane says, he had been using Flickr to manage his
personal photos and loved it. "So in March and April of this year,
we started talking to the guys over at Flickr about the idea of
building a distributed photo approval and storage application around
their API." An API -- application program interface -- is a bit of
software that enables different programs to talk to each other. "The
goal," he says, "was to allow users to upload and view photos from
any MoveOn event, while making sure that inappropriate pictures got
filtered out."

The system they built has two main parts: an email based photo
uploader and a distributed photo approval application. It works like
this, according to Kane:

We setup an email account for a campaign. Campaigners can associate
any number of tags with that email account. Folks email photos in as
attachments. A script looks at each email, finds the ones that have
photos and uploads them to Flickr. On the MoveOn side, we keep some
metadata about the photo: when it was uploaded, whether the person
who sent them in was a MoveOn user or not etc.

At this point, the photos are all private -- the public can't view
them. So, MoveOn volunteers use the "photo booth" application to
review uploaded photos. Each photo gets at least two votes. If it's
approved, the photo is marked public and becomes part of the Flickr
photostream. Volunteers can also flag photos as "great", so we can
quickly cherry pick great photos to highlight to MoveOn members.

By all indications, the system is working well. Since so many people
are already familiar with emailing photos to friends or family,
MoveOn's email-based uploading process is a snap. And the photo
approval process has turned into a great way to involve MoveOn
volunteers. Kane reports that when the group was testing the review
application, it asked volunteers to review 7,000 photos from
previous events. "The folks that responded to the ask went through
all 7,000 photos in less than 50 minutes and were disappointed when
we ran out of pics for them to look at. Great stuff!"

Power to the edges?

Apart from being able to save server space and involve volunteers,
MoveOn's engagement with Flickr has had some unexpected benefits
that come precisely from using a platform that is designed to push
power to the users. Kane recalls, "One of our campaigners wanted a
slideshow of photos from a recent action and was able to put it
together himself, just by selecting the tags he was interested in
and using the Flickr slideshow app." He adds, "It's also made
finding pictures for the MoveOn homepage and other materials a snap -
- MoveOn staff can easily browse photos by campaign or time period."

And so can you. Kane says there have been more than a quarter
million viewings of MoveOn's photos on Flickr, and that's without
the group ever directly informing its members of the resource.
MoveOn is also discovering lots of new contacts among Flickr users
who have stumbled across its photos.

Though MoveOn is making only limited use of the Flickr toolset on
its own homepage, where members are pointed to a simple slideshow,
in the future Kane expects "to point folks towards the 'most viewed'
or 'most interesting' lists for a given campaign, just like we point
people to the photos that our volunteer reviewers have flagged
as 'great' now." He's also thinking of adding geographic information
to their photo-set, since they already know which event every photo
has come from, and combining that with the Google Maps API to create
instant national, state and local maps.

Where all this may lead is unclear. MoveOn members could start to
use the group's Flickr pages to engage in some lateral communication
with each other, for example, since Flickr encourages people to
leave comments on photos and also enables group forums. But it's not
likely that will happen without some instigation from the group's

The larger lesson for other organizations is this: As social
networking sites like Flickr, del.icio.us (also just bought by
Yahoo!), and MySpace attract millions of users, it may make sense to
go where the people already are and start playing with the same
tools, not only because those tools may offer all kinds of benefits
to the organization, but also to see what unexpected benefits may
engage people. What MoveOn is doing with Flickr is just a beginning.

------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
AIDS in India: A "lurking bomb." Click and help stop AIDS now.

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    technoliberation-unsubscribe at yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:

----- End forwarded message -----
Eugen* Leitl <a href="http://leitl.org">leitl</a> http://leitl.org
ICBM: 48.07100, 11.36820            http://www.ativel.com
8B29F6BE: 099D 78BA 2FD3 B014 B08A  7779 75B0 2443 8B29 F6BE

[demime 1.01d removed an attachment of type application/pgp-signature which had a name of signature.asc]

More information about the cypherpunks-legacy mailing list