FC: Hollywood wants to plug "analog hole," regulate A-D converters
eresrch at eskimo.com
Thu May 30 06:43:40 PDT 2002
On Thu, 30 May 2002, Nomen Nescio wrote:
> This is absurd. In all the commentary on this issue, no one has made
> the obvious point that the MPAA has no interest or intention in putting
> watermark detectors into every ADC chip! They don't care about the ADC
If they don't they are screwed.
> chip in a digital thermometer or even a cell phone. All they care about
> are things like PC video capture cards, which are high fidelty consumer
> devices capable of digitizing copyright protected content.
And everyone outside the US will build their cards without the detector,
or with a software switch to turn it off so they can sell more in the US.
> Their white paper is a brief summary of their goals and intentions and
> does not go into full technical detail. But let's use a little common
> sense here, folks.
Common sense says they are corrupt pigs who will stop at nothing to
get their profits back up.
> It's pointless to try to shoot down this proposal by raising all these
> horror stories about ADC chips in industrial and technical devices
> being crippled by a watermark detector which will never be activated.
> If you waste time developing this line of argument, you will be left
> with nothing to say when the actual bill focuses only on the specific
> devices that the content holders are worried about.
And what are they going to do when people build MP3 players from auto
ADC's that don't detect watermarks? Make them illegal?
> And sure, a sufficiently talented electrical engineer can produce a custom
> board to do non-watermark-aware ADC, and digitize TV shows and music.
> The MPAA has to accept that such activity will continue to go on at a
> low level. They just want to make sure that consumer devices are not
> sold that enable every customer to make easy digital copies of copyrighted
> data based on an analog source, as they can now with the Replay DVR.
And what's to prevent it from happening at a high level if there's
enough profit in it? MPAA is a tiny market compared to the rest of
the electronics industry - it will be easy to bypass the law on a
huge scale. You don't need to be a "sufficiently talented electrical
engineer" when you can go across the border, buy 1000 simple/cheap
devices and bring 'em back in your pickup truck.
> Please, let's use some common sense and not go overboard with an obviously
> mistaken interpretation of the MPAA's intentions. That wastes everyone's
MPAA is definitly a waste of everybody's time. They need to be shot
so we don't have to listen to them anymore!!!
Patience, persistence, truth,
More information about the cypherpunks-legacy