Final Carnivore Report Offers No New Answers

mmotyka at lsil.com mmotyka at lsil.com
Fri Dec 15 12:59:40 PST 2000


It's all well and good to hear this coming from a Congressman but this
is a Republican Congressman who is using it as a opportunity to attack a
Democratic Administration : should we read anything into this statement
regarding some significant difference between the two parties in regards
privacy and 4th Ammendment issues? 

Hardly.

Mike

> This just in from US House Majority Leader Dick Armey:
> 
> - Final Carnivore Report Offers No New Answers
> A newly released, final version of the report on the Carnivore
> cybersnooping system offers no assurance that online transactions
> will be kept confidential.
>
> http://freedom.gov/library/technology/carn-review3.asp
> 
> US House Majority Leader Dick Armey made the following comments about 
> the newly released, final report on the Carnivore cybersnooping 
> system: This superficial review doesn't get to the heart of the 
> matter. It does nothing to restore the confidence that Americans 
> should have in the confidentiality of their online transactions.
> 
> Why should average Internet users have to wonder whether a rogue 
> agent could snoop through their emails and other online transactions?
> 
> If this Administration were actually interested in an honest 
> evaluation of Carnivore, it would have shut the system down until the 
> serious privacy concerns had been adequately addressed. Instead, this 
> review by a team with clear ties to this Administration raises more 
> concerns than it answers.
> 
> Regards,  Matt-
>





More information about the cypherpunks-legacy mailing list