Buying Mein Kampf via the Net

Lizard lizard at mrlizard.com
Sun Dec 3 20:02:49 PST 2000


At 07:49 PM 12/3/2000, Danny Yee wrote:
>Lizard wrote:
> > Really? Doesn't the Berne convention override national laws?
>
>Probably, yes.  Does that mean national copyright laws only apply to
>their own citizens/residents?  What happens in the case of dual
>citizenship?  And does place of publication come into it?

In most cases, national laws are altered to bring them 'in line' with 
treaties. (All treaties.) This has been an issue in the US, where the SC 
has ruled that a treaty cannot violate the constitution...or, rather, that 
it doesn't matter WHAT Congress agreed to, the Constitution will trump any 
laws passed to institute it.

That this might somehow change is a favorite paranoia of a loony right. 
(And, were it likely to occur, it would be a justifiable paranoia...it 
would allow the legislature to do an end-run around the Bill of Rights. For 
example, the US as it stands CANNOT ban 'hate speech' from US-hosted 
servers, even if Europe pressured them into signing a treaty to do so.)





More information about the cypherpunks-legacy mailing list