New by me at BradBlog/BradCast: Elections breach cover-up in rural town with national implications
Hello cypherpunks, Today the BradBlog <https://BradBlog.com>, run for two decades and counting by journalist Brad Friedman -- of the syndicated United States FM radio show, the BradCast -- published my new in-depth investigative article regarding rural, Republican-leaning Coffee County down south in the swing state of Georgia, and then interviewed me for his radio show. Here's the title, subtitle, and hyperlink for the article component: /A secret meeting within a secret meeting: Unspooling the Coffee County, Georgia voting system breach and continuing cover-up/ <https://bradblog.com/?p=14697> subtitled /Cracks emerge in wall of secrecy surrounding mysterious County meeting in small town conspiracy with national implications.../ You might want to read this. I dug into scores of federal court documents to turn a sprawling story into a highly readable narrative of a little over 3500 words. As you probably know, Georgia is a battleground state. Less known, top Trumpers -- Sidney Powell et al. -- have been executing a multistate scheme to breach county elections offices and swipe software for computerized voting, presumably for hacks/rigs and/or sprinkling into their disinformation campaigns for added (pseudo-)plausibility. Georgia's Secretary of State, who's the elections head for Georgia, recently told a federal judge that his office will /not/ apply Homeland Security CISA-recommended security patches related to the breach until /after/ the 2024 general elections. Unfortunately for the conspirators, the rural county officials in question are not exactly skilled at evading Georgia public meetings transparency law, and that's where your trustily thorough, info-dense Douglas Lucas is holding them to account, though it likely will require more pushing, such as litigation to force the county boards to obey the open meetings laws. Earlier today for the associated FM radio spot, I recorded my part from West Seattle. Today's Bradcast show, 58 minutes in length, is downloadable in full as an .MP3 below. The Coffee County intro segment with me -- some 4 minutes total in length -- begins at 02:24, ends at 06:48, and the main Coffee County portion with me -- some 41 minutes total in length -- begins at 16:57, concludes at 57:07. Or if you really want to jump straight to my part of the main part (which is about 20 minutes in legnth) without the preceding summary of my article, jump straight to 37:00 and continue to 57:07. Landing page for today's radio show, has links to iTunes and others carrying the BradCast (such as Apple Podcasts <https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/bradcast-6-21-2023-exclusive-ga-vote-system-breach/id803467610?i=1000617914940>): https://bradblog.com/?p=14700 <https://bradblog.com/?p=14700>58-minute MP3 direct download link: https://bradblog.com/audio/BradCast_BradFriedman-FreemanMossClearedGA_Dougla... Thanks for your time, consideration, and informed effort to improve things, Douglas
On 6/21/23, Douglas Lucas <dal@riseup.net> wrote:
"speculation is all that's possible." The article debunks itself right there. Just as pathetic as Rat's emptywheel and palmerreport articles. And the public, thus any members of it, has right to obtain inspect copy and distribute all election SW and HW as they see fit. And if you can't build a voting machine that can stand up to even such basic attacks, then quit using fucking voting machines. Nor do we see Douglas Lucas acknowledging the actual well known election fraud facts, such as the TWITTER FILES, Wholly Biased Democrat Controlled Fake News Media, CRIMINAL IMPEACHABLE Joe Biden's $10Million bribes, Hillary Russia Hoax, 50 Deep State Agents signed Biden Laptop coverup letter, the two false impeachments, the Zuckerberg Soros Gates limitless millions of fraudulent democrat electioneering partnerships, violent gun toting murdering Democrats endorsing and inciting the threatening summer of violence, breaking state election laws, plandemic3, yet more free-shit handouts, and much more. Lucas would do better to copy the SW himself and try to exploit and publicly expose the silly machines that way, instead of trying to claim without any evidence whatsoever that hundreds of individual Repub voters are going to walk up to vote and exploit the machines in realtime on election day via the touchscreens to modify counts within count anomaly detection thresholds, because that's all that *copying* will let you do without discoverably breaking physical seals to upload new code. Trump probably wasn't far off when estimating that just the known facts above contributed ~17% vote shift, none of which involved touching any vote machine at all. Even if putting the known fraud influence at 5%, Trump still won. And Democracy is a violent failed scam that will never work. Whether you like or accept those facts or not is irrelevant.
Contrary to Grarpamp's misleadingly abridged quotation of me, I actually wrote in my article: "To date, speculation is all that's possible" referring specifically to the identity of the party or parties issuing legal threats to Coffee County. "To date" because I believe open meetings law will eventually enable journalists/litigants to make it clear who the party or parties were. But Grarpamp if you already have tangible proof of the legal threat(s) beyond what to date can be reasonably speculated, feel free to publish it now and thereby help everyone. There are definitely arguments to be made for openly publishing the Dominion Voting Systems proprietary code -- a la the Vault 7 megaleak -- but these MAGA or MAGA-ish operatives who intruded on the Coffee County elections building have NOT done that. They have only made (portions of?) the code available, in contrast, to a subset of their own allies for their own partisan purposes, more Leak Keeper-type behavior. And, as at CPAC recently, they have misrepresented what the proprietary code they made off with contains. Setting aside the actual operatives' actual dishonest and illegal actions, someone could counter-argue that making the Dominion proprietary code openly available would be less like Vault 7 and more like jeopardizing needed social services -- e.g., fire trucks, hospitals -- that in today's world are unfortunately run by the state. There are legit experts now, e.g. J Alex Halderman, assessing the code, and all that's linked in my article, including Halderman's report recently unsealed by the federal judge in the case against the Georgia Secretary of State. Grarpamp's takes reflect his failure of basic reading comprehension. So one could assume if the Dominion Voting Systems code is someday leaked openly in full -- and it may well be before all this is over -- Grarpamp would not be among these able to read it and produce thoughtful analysis. Doug On 2023-06-22 09:19, grarpamp wrote:
On 6/21/23, Douglas Lucas <dal@riseup.net> wrote:
"speculation is all that's possible."
The article debunks itself right there. Just as pathetic as Rat's emptywheel and palmerreport articles.
And the public, thus any members of it, has right to obtain inspect copy and distribute all election SW and HW as they see fit.
And if you can't build a voting machine that can stand up to even such basic attacks, then quit using fucking voting machines.
Nor do we see Douglas Lucas acknowledging the actual well known election fraud facts, such as the TWITTER FILES, Wholly Biased Democrat Controlled Fake News Media, CRIMINAL IMPEACHABLE Joe Biden's $10Million bribes, Hillary Russia Hoax, 50 Deep State Agents signed Biden Laptop coverup letter, the two false impeachments, the Zuckerberg Soros Gates limitless millions of fraudulent democrat electioneering partnerships, violent gun toting murdering Democrats endorsing and inciting the threatening summer of violence, breaking state election laws, plandemic3, yet more free-shit handouts, and much more.
Lucas would do better to copy the SW himself and try to exploit and publicly expose the silly machines that way, instead of trying to claim without any evidence whatsoever that hundreds of individual Repub voters are going to walk up to vote and exploit the machines in realtime on election day via the touchscreens to modify counts within count anomaly detection thresholds, because that's all that *copying* will let you do without discoverably breaking physical seals to upload new code.
Trump probably wasn't far off when estimating that just the known facts above contributed ~17% vote shift, none of which involved touching any vote machine at all.
Even if putting the known fraud influence at 5%, Trump still won. And Democracy is a violent failed scam that will never work. Whether you like or accept those facts or not is irrelevant.
My attempt at my conventional thoughts and opinions: - Given we have seen chip manufacturers placing hidden hardware backdoors in common microcontrollers, it seems like the use of almost any voting machine would severely undermine the intent of democracy, unless the contents are presented for full public review. - The cryptographic software communities have developed working examples of transparent voting protocols for decades now, in the hopes of these things being adopted by governments. These are some of the same groups that have struggled as politics have heaved. [sorry, i had a couple more items but I've forgotten them. i've only read a little bit of the article, it's intense, it's great to see] It's notable that there are a number of different severely important things here. Many different important and dangerous topics are involved here at once. This can make it hard to integrate the material and possibly easier for partisan influences to change the story.
Today the BradBlog <https://BradBlog.com>, run for two decades and counting by journalist Brad Friedman -- of the syndicated United States FM radio show, the BradCast -- published my new in-depth investigative article regarding rural, Republican-leaning Coffee County down south in the swing state of Georgia, and then interviewed me for his radio show. Here's the title, subtitle, and hyperlink for the article component: *A secret meeting within a secret meeting: Unspooling the Coffee County, Georgia voting system breach and continuing cover-up* <https://bradblog.com/?p=14697> subtitled *Cracks emerge in wall of secrecy surrounding mysterious County meeting in small town conspiracy with national implications...*
*- The BRAD BLOG - https://bradblog.com <https://bradblog.com> -* A Secret Meeting Within a Secret Meeting: Unspooling the Coffee County, Georgia Voting System Breach and Continuing Cover-Up Cracks emerge in wall of secrecy surrounding mysterious County meeting in small town conspiracy with national implications... *** An exclusive BRAD BLOG investigation Posted By *Douglas Lucas* On 21st June 2023 @ 09:35 In *Election Irregularities*, *Georgia*, *Election Fraud*, *National Security*, *Accountability*, *Dominion Voting*, *Donald Trump*, *Election 2020*, *Brad Raffensperger*, *Sidney Powell*, *CISA*, *Insurrection*, *Mike Lindell*, *Election 2024*, *Fani Willis*, *Coffee County* | *No Comments* At first glance, a closed-door executive session of the Board of Elections at the Coffee County Courthouse in the battleground state of Georgia appeared to involve nothing more than discussion of that day's resignation letters <https://bradblog.comhttps//douglasnow.com/index.php/news/item/8778-board-of-elections-accepts-employee-resignations-election-office-temporarily-closed> [1] from then-Election Supervisor Misty Hampton <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/MistyHamptonResignationLetter_25February2021.pdf> [2] and her assistant <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/JilRidlehooverResignationLetter_25February2021.pdf> [3] over their purported cheating on timesheets. But the previously undisclosed, simultaneous presence of an unacknowledged quorum of County Commissioners at that executive session --- a secret meeting during a secret meeting, a game-changer confirmed by The BRAD BLOG <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com> [4] --- combined with curious *doth protest too much* efforts the County is still using to defend its secrets about the supposedly humdrum assembly, indicate the February 25, 2021 meetings (now known as meetings *plural*) and surrounding events were the nexus of a much broader statewide, perhaps even nationwide, cover-up. That night, the very same reputedly run-of-the-mill Thursday in February when the elections board gathered at the Courthouse, MyPillow founder and close Trump associate Mike Lindell --- a chief Stop the Steal bankroller --- landed his private jet in the county's tiny seat of Douglas, population 11,685. A few hours earlier, flight records show <https://bradblog.comhttps//twitter.com/MacFinn44/status/1365437816080109576> [5], he landed in D.C. A few hours before that, his plane took off from a runway not 15 miles from the private Mar-a-Lago club belonging to a certain twice-impeached Florida Man named Donald J. Trump. Why did Lindell fly so circuitously from the Palm Beach area to the nation's capital and then back down south to rural Coffee County, of all places? And why did he want to speak with Misty Hampton, Coffee's resigning Election Supervisor? Evidence <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_KurtOlsenMistyHamptonEdVoylesMessages_February2021.pdf> [6] yielded from a years-long lawsuit by actual election experts challenging Georgia's Dominion voting system has revealed that the far-right bedding baron's lawyer, Kurt Olsen, tried to get ahold of Hampton the previous evening to talk, as word spread that she'd be dismissed the next day. Why would he want to do *that*? Over the January prior to the unexplained meeting(s) --- in fact, beginning just the day after armed and violent Trump supporters assailed <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-J6-REPORT/pdf/GPO-J6-REPORT.pdf> [7] the U.S. Capitol in hopes of preventing Joe Biden's 2020 election victory --- a motley mix of mostly MAGA operatives illicitly entered the Coffee County elections building on multiple occasions. The breach was funded and organized <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/invoice.html> [8] by Trump attorney Sidney Powell, that prolific and since-sanctioned <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.michigan.gov/-/media/Project/Websites/AG/opinions/172_opinion__order_King.pdf?rev=094b2bd4f3e141a1b9bb5aff9ee2cf6a> [9] filer of failed <https://bradblog.comhttps//lostnotstolen.org/> [10] lawsuits seeking to steal Biden's 2020 win. One client of the breach-funding Powell, it turns out, was "fake elector" Cathy Latham, the former Coffee County GOP chair. Latham was found to have helped facilitate --- and to have lied <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_ExhibitRegardingLathamLies_19September2022.pdf> [11] about her presence during --- the breach at the elections office, where the invited intruders copied Dominion's proprietary software that is still to be used in the 2024 Presidential election in Georgia and numerous jurisdictions beyond. Hampton, as director of elections for the Republican-leaning county, welcomed the Powell-paid team into the local elections office to have at the voting equipment, tabulators and sensitive election management systems. With statewide voting systems gravely compromised <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_HaldermanDominionBMDSecurityAnalysis_1July2021Unsealed14June2023.pdf> [12] by the ensuing breach --- Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger forces every county to use the same touchscreens, also employed in more than a dozen states <https://bradblog.comhttps//verifiedvoting.org/verifier/#mode/search/year/2024/make/Dominion> [13] nationwide --- and with traces of top Trumpers everywhere, the scandal is, as the county seat's Mayor Pro Tem recently put it <https://bradblog.comhttps//youtu.be/Rjw2cIHxyfQ?t=2162> [14], "only getting bigger." Indeed, Atlanta-based District Attorney Fani Willis is reportedly <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2023/06/02/trump-georgia-election-investigation-fulton-county/> [15] investigating the Coffee County breach, along with Team Trump's multistate plot to gain access to and copy data from voting systems in other states as well. The scheme, as we have since learned <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/?p=14643> [16], was hatched <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.nytimes.com/2023/04/21/us/trump-voting-software-2020-election.html> [17] during a notorious December 2020 meeting <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.nytimes.com/2022/07/12/us/dec-18-meeting-jan-6-trump.html> [18] in the Oval Office with Trump present. That fact came to light in testimony <https://bradblog.comhttps//freespeechforpeople.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/doj.sp_.coffee.j6.4.18.23.pdf> [19] to the U.S. House subcommittee that investigated <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-J6-TRANSCRIPT-CTRL0000055541/pdf/GPO-J6-TRANSCRIPT-CTRL0000055541.pdf> [20] January 6th. Frustrated, fighting back tears, Douglas Mayor Pro Tem Olivia Pearson, a lifelong Coffee resident and voting rights activist <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.vera.org/in-our-backyards-stories/this-is-by-design> [21] in the majority black seat of the majority white county, said at a recent gathering as the reality of the breach finally began galvanizing local residents, "We have *got* to make it right. We can't keep covering it up!" Starting in earnest last month, local residents have increasingly attended the Board of Elections' open meetings, only to be told, more than once, by its unapologetic Chairman Wendell Stone --- who some locals are said to describe as "Chairman Stone(wall)" --- to stop asking questions. Of course, that makes us want to ask many *more* questions about what really happened among the cows and cornstalks in the rural Peach State county. Such as: Why did Hampton and her assistant who helped facilitate the unlawful Trump/Powell/MAGA breach to illicitly copy and distribute Coffee County's sensitive voting system software *actually* tender their resignations on February 25, 2021?; Did local and state officials know about the breach and attempt to cover it up with secret meetings? What on Earth was Mike Lindell doing there for several hours that night?; And why has the office of Republican Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, heralded by some as a 'moderate Republican' hero for *not* <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.wsj.com/articles/listen-to-the-full-trump-ga-call-11609713527> [22] helping Trump steal the state's election in 2020, denied the severity of the breach and lied by both omission and commission to aid in covering it all up <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/coveritallup.html> [23] ? And, yes, all of this matters at the *national* level --- not only to the Coffee residents, who have lately found themselves in a fight they never asked for over their beloved county's soul... *'Increased risks' for the entire nation* On New Year's Day 2021, Jennifer Jackson, an employee at Atlanta cyber forensics firm SullivanStrickler, received a typo-ridden text-message from Trump lawyer Katherine Friess referring to her recent D.C. meeting with Rudy Giuliani, onetime Trump attorney and former New York City Mayor. "Hi! Just *h*anded back in DC with the Mayor. Huge things starting to come together!" the misspelled message began. "Most immediately," Friess continued, "we were granted access --- by written invitation! --- to the Coffee County Syste*n*s. Yay!" Jackson, along with other supposed computer experts from SullivanStrickler would, about a week later, breach the Coffee elections building for what their invoice to Sidney Powell would term "Voting Machines Analysis." However, no such written invitation as Friess mentions has yet materialized. Coffee Elections Board Chair Wendell Stone testified under oath in a deposition <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_WendellStoneDeposition_1September2022.pdf> [24] that on "behalf of the Board, no authority was granted to examine our systems, our computers, our data." Friess' celebratory text <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/celebratorymessage.html> [25] to Jackson, and Stone's apparent denial, both surfaced in *Curling v. Raffensperger*, an ongoing court case launched in July 2017. The plaintiffs demand Georgia's Secretary of State Raffensperger replace his new, unverifiable <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/?p=14693> [26] $150 million polling place touchscreen systems with hand-marked paper ballots tabulated by robustly audited <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.stat.berkeley.edu/~stark/Preprints/gentle12.pdf> [27] optical scanners. Many cybersecurity and voting system experts <https://bradblog.comhttps//georgetownlawtechreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/4.2-p523-541-Appel-Stark.pdf> [28] agree <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_HaldermanDominionBMDSecurityAnalysis_1July2021Unsealed14June2023.pdf> [29] the change would dramatically improve election integrity and security. They had, in fact, strongly urged Raffensperger to move to such a system after the federal judge in the *Curling* case found <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/?p=13101> [30] Georgia's previous touchscreen systems too vulnerable to ever use again after 2019. News stories <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CGGandFSFP_SummaryOfMajorMediaAndMore_May2022toApril2023.pdf> [31] over the past year --- including by major corporate media outlets --- have detailed <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.cnn.com/2022/09/06/politics/surveillance-video-voting-machine-breach-coffee-county-georgia/index.html> [32] the security camera surveillance footage and other evidence documenting the Jan. 7 through Jan. 29 illicit entrances at the Coffee County elections building in 2021. As the stunning transgressions gradually came to light, the *Curling* plaintiffs used them in federal court as an object lesson in the gaping vulnerabilities plaguing Georgia's new, replacement touchscreen systems. In the words of one of the plaintiffs' computer security experts, Kevin Skoglund, in his sworn December 2022 declaration <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_KevinSkoglundDeclaration_5December2022.pdf> [33], the intruders collected and distributed "protected software from almost every component of Georgia's election system." Now, he warns <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.latimes.com/politics/story/2023-03-30/election-machines-cpac> [34], "adversaries may use the software in disinformation campaigns or study it to learn how to subvert its operation." As a result, he added, "all of Georgia's counties and other states must endure increased risks." Examination of the breach makes it impossible to interpret the activities as anything other than a flagrant violation of Georgia law <https://bradblog.comhttps//rules.sos.ga.gov/gac/183-1-12-.05?urlRedirected=yes&data=admin&lookingfor=183-1-12-.05> [35], as Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis appears to have noticed. Furthermore, the matter has cast a dark, looming cloud over the 2024 election in both Georgia and other states where the same sensitive equipment will be used again next year. In Georgia, the systems are scheduled for use *without* critical security patches strongly recommended <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.cisa.gov/news-events/ics-advisories/icsa-22-154-01> [36] by the U.S. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA). Raffensperger's office recently told <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/?p=14659> [37] the federal judge in *Curling* that Dominion's certified upgrades will *not* be installed in the swing-state until *after* next year's Presidential election. Cybersecurity experts have said such a delay in patching security holes now gives potential attackers 18 months to exploit vulnerabilities spilled due to the Coffee breach. Then-election supervisor Misty Hampton was there in Coffee County, complicit, every single day of the criminal breach. Roughly a month later, when Mike Lindell's lawyer was texting her to schedule a chat, Hampton also received a separate text <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/GroupMessages_ChaneyThomasEThomasClarkMcCulloughStone_24February2021.pdf> [38] from Board of Elections member Matthew McCullough. McCullough told Hampton (and others on the Board's group-text) that County Attorney Tony Rowell requested "discussing any conversations about elections with him first," adding: "we have another new lawsuit and the possibility of another after that." New and potential litigation was on their minds the day before the next afternoon's still-mysterious February 25, 2021 meeting(s). As far as lawsuits are concerned, however, the published minutes <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CoffeeCountyElectionsBoard_Agenda_25February2021.pdf> [39] for the meeting refer only to a need to go into a closed-door executive session to discuss as-yet unexplained "PENDING OR POTENTIAL LITIGATION, SETTLEMENT, CLAIMS, ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS, OR OTHER JUDICIAL ACTIONS BROUGHT OR TO BE BROUGHT BY OR AGAINST THE COUNTY." The meeting was properly and publicly noticed in advance <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/MistyHamptonEricChaneyTextMessages_MeetingPublicNotice_FebruaryMarch2021.pdf> [40], and elections board Members assembled on Feb. 25, 2021, though not in their usual spot, the elections building. Instead, they gathered in the County Commissioners meeting room on the County Courthouse's ground floor. Among the members present was Eric Chaney, who had participated in the January breach and ultimately resigned from the Board of Elections in August 2022. Under oath in a *Curling v. Raffensperger* deposition <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_EricChaneyDeposition_15August2022.pdf> [41] three days following his resignation, he oddly explained he'd stepped down abruptly because he'd moved from one district to another. That's not a reason <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/notareason.html> [42] that would mandate he quit. Chaney invoked the Fifth Amendment during his deposition just shy of 250 times <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/250.html> [43], despite being warned early on that citing the Fifth in the civil, not criminal, proceeding meant the court could infer such statements undermine him. The warning was prompted by Chaney pleading "Fifth Amendment" when asked to confirm if he'd destroyed all his communications with Misty Hampton. Elections officials, including Chaney and Hampton, have a legal duty to preserve all such correspondence related to their election roles. In fact, the Board now claims to have lost *all* of Hampton's emails *and* those of her assistant. *All of them*. That's about where matters lay by last summer. The secretive gathering --- purportedly to discuss Hampton and her assistant's mere timesheet discrepancies and/or something litigation related --- remained a black hole, with little light of knowledge escaping what the Douglas Mayor Pro Tem would this month call a cover-up. *Shadowy meeting. Missing documentation.* Public minutes for the Feb. 25, 2021 meeting not produced and signed <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CoffeeCountyElectionsBoardPublicMinutes_Signed_25Feb2021ProducedOct2022.pdf> [44] until Oct. 2022, over a year and a half later, when the nonprofit Coalition for Good Governance <https://bradblog.comhttps//coalitionforgoodgovernance.org> [45], a plaintiff in *Curling v. Raffensperger*, successfully demanded them from the County. In retrospect, the concise document <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CoffeeCountyElectionsBoardPublicMinutes_Unsigned_25Feb2021ProducedOct2022.pdf> [46], just 200-ish words in length, serves as a sign that Misty Hampton's timesheets were little more than an attempted smokescreen. The tardy minutes say little more than that the Board of Elections went into a closed-door executive session, meaning they granted themselves secrecy. According to the public minutes, the Board cloaked their conversation for two reasons permitted under certain circumstances: employment and litigation. The first --- deliberating on dismissal or disciplinary matters --- presumably refers to Hampton and her assistant's resignations. The second, the sole other purpose given in the belated minutes for executive secrecy, was to consult with County Attorney Tony Rowell --- who is documented as being present at the meeting --- about pending/potential litigation. It seems implausible that the "new lawsuit and the possibility of another" that Matthew McCullough referred to in the Board of Elections group-text the night before revolved around dismissing Hampton due to purported timesheet cheating. So what was the incoming litigation really about in that month following the Coffee County voting software breach? And who had threatened or brought it? To speculate, ponder the interests of Secretary of State Raffensperger's office or Dominion Voting Systems, either or both of which, if they'd learned of the January breach, could have pressured the Coffee elections body on pain of a lawsuit. Georgia's embattled elections chief might have demanded Coffee County turn over --- or conceal --- some bit of evidence, maybe to preemptively gain some control over the potentially embarrassing or discrediting story before it hit any headlines. We reached out to Raffensperger's office and will update if answered. So far, although their website <https://bradblog.comhttps//sos.ga.gov/> [47] continues trumpeting "secure" elections, they aren't talking. Dominion, despite their longstanding silence on the topic of their sensitive, proprietary, and highly vulnerable <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/?p=14693> [48] voting systems being breached, copied, and distributed via the Internet, has stubbornly refused <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/stubbornrefusal.html> [49] to produce related public records. A spokesperson's boilerplate response <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/boilerplate.html> [50] revealed little sign of concern for the obvious risk of massive reputational damage to their systems nationwide. To date, speculation is all that's possible. Coffee County has yet to publicly identify the purported litigation referenced by the text-message or public minutes, even though the Association of County Commissioners of Georgia (ACCG) guide to open meetings <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.accg.org/library/legal/Open%20Meetings%20and%20Open%20Records%20Laws%202016.pdf> [51] cites case law <https://bradblog.comhttps//bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/AppealsCourtGeorgia_ClaxtonEnterpriseVEvansCtyBdComm_6June2001.pdf> [52] to say "mere fear or suspicion of being sued" isn't enough to justify executive session secrecy --- instead, to use a legal threat as a basis for cloaking conversations, a board must be able to produce tangible proof, such as a written demand letter, of the pending/potential litigation in question. Marilyn Marks, the Executive Director of the Coalition for Good Governance, told us the County has yet to produce a tangible lawsuit threat matching both McCullough's Feb. 24, 2021 group-text about a "new lawsuit and the possibility of another" *and* use of litigation in the belated minutes as the justification for executive session secrecy. Our review of scores of emails between the nonprofit watchdog organization and County attorney Jennifer Herzog --- constituting open records requests and her official responses --- demonstrates the Coffee County Board of Elections failed and continues to fail in its legal duty to correctly document the shadowy Courthouse meeting. For the secretive gathering, the elections board has produced only terse and cryptic *public* minutes, even though Georgia open meetings law <https://bradblog.comhttps//law.georgia.gov/document/here-4/download> [53] mandates a Board must record minutes for executive sessions as well, even if they remain unpublished, so a judge may review them confidentially if need be. The body must similarly "execute and file with the official minutes a notarized affidavit" when asserting executive secrecy, describing "the reason for closing the meeting and swearing that the meeting was limited to the topics allowed by law." In response to a Coalition records requests this year, Attorney Herzog wrote on April 28: "I am not aware of any executive session minutes in existence at this time." Herzog's response regarding the affidavit was just as bad. Formally asked by the nonprofit watchdog to produce the legally-mandated notarized attestation for the Feb. 25, 2021 executive session at the courthouse, Herzog answered on March 24 of this year that it was her "understanding there are no records in Coffee County's possession responsive" to that request. She added that she was not "aware of any [responsive] documents" held by her law firm, Hall Booth Smith, a major outfit with more than 400+ attorneys nationwide. The absent executive minutes, apparently nonexistent notarized affidavit, and missing tangible proof of legal threats --- which, if published, would identify any powerful players who were making demands of the County --- combine to argue that the shadowy meeting's executive session was illegitimate (a nice way of saying *illegal*), and that the Board of Elections thereby owes everyone new, correct minutes documenting what really happened. *Cracking a cover-up's wall of secrecy?* The BRAD BLOG has now uncovered and confirmed with several members present at the secretive meeting that Coffee County has yet *another* problem. Namely, that the tardy minutes are lies since they include no mention that the Board of Elections was joined that day at the Courthouse by a quorum of *County Commissioners* --- the county's governing authority. That quorum officially constituted a public meeting of *that* body as well, a public meeting which is also required, under law, to be publicly noticed in advance and recorded via official minutes. No public notice announced the County Commissioners meeting within a meeting. Official minutes are nowhere to be found. In fact, County Attorney Herzog maintains that *no quorum of Commissioners met*! Earlier this month, on June 4, after months of tight-lipped officials in Coffee refusing to go on record about what *actually* happened at that February 2021 meeting, Oscar Paulk, the only black member of Coffee's County Commission, finally confirmed to us that he did, in fact, attend the Feb. 25, 2021 elections board meeting. Word of Paulk's confirmation quickly made its way around. At a public meeting of the Board earlier this month, on June 6, 2023 --- just two days after we were able to confirm the first crack in the Commissioners' wall of secrecy --- Georgia activist Kathryn Grant asked <https://bradblog.comhttps//youtu.be/Rjw2cIHxyfQ?t=2030> [54] if anyone besides Paulk remembered Commissioners attending the Feb. 25, 2021 Board of Elections executive session. No one spoke up. Chairman Wendell Stone stonewalled as follows: "We're not accepting questions. The Board is not accepting questions. I am not accepting questions." Nevertheless, she persisted, and Stone man-terrupted: "We're not accepting questions. And please don't pose another question." In fact, Paulk had confirmed that a *trio* of County Commissioners --- himself, A.J. Dovers and Ted O'Steen --- did, in fact, attend the elections board's session at the Courthouse that day. The admissions did not come easily, some 28 months after the meeting took place. Two Board of Elections members, likewise on record, and only *after* this month's June 6 meeting, confirmed Paulk's admission. Ernestine Thomas-Clark --- the sole black member of the board, who votes a Democratic ballot --- confirmed to us on June 7. Air Force veteran Andy Thomas similarly confirmed it to us the next day. (Despite the similar surnames, there's no relation between the two.) Yes, an official *quorum* of County Commissioners <https://bradblog.comhttps//qpublic.net/ga/coffee/index-com.html> [55] attended the shadowy Board of Elections meeting. Why? And why were the other two Commissioners not there? Georgia's legislation enabling <https://bradblog.comhttps//www.legis.ga.gov/api/legislation/document/20132014/135112> [56] the Coffee County Board of Commissioners states that "three board members shall constitute a quorum." The ACCG's legal guide spells out the significance: "Meetings that must comply with the open meetings law include the gathering of a quorum of a board of commissioners...at which any official business, policy, or public matter of the county is formulated, presented, discussed, or voted upon." The meeting *was*, in fact, official business. Oscar Paulk told us, also on June 4, that the Board of Elections invited the County Commissioners with the purpose of discussing, on Feb. 25, 2021, Misty Hampton and "what to do about her." In response, the Commissioners, as Paulk tells it, presented their view that the fate of the then-Election Supervisor was a decision for the elections board to formulate. But why were *eight* senior members of County government --- plus the County Attorney --- present for what one source described as a "task more fitting for the Human Resources staff"? Mundane HR matter or not, the presence of three Commissioners listening to the five-person elections body decide upon a governmental employment matter certainly fits "a quorum of a board of commissioners at which...official business...[is] discussed." That's true even if the County Commissioners' quorum was brief and quick to wash their hands of the subject --- though to be clear, that hasn't been established. In other words, it wasn't one board of officials assembling at the Courthouse that day, it was two. A secret meeting within a secret meeting. With a quorum of Commissioners, statutory transparency obligations kick in: the Coffee County Board of Commissioners legally owes everyone public minutes documenting exactly what took place at the long-ago meeting. The Coffee Board of Elections must correct their existing *public* minutes as well. The two concurrent meetings had at least some significant duration of overlap, and possibly started and ended at the same or nearly the same time (or not). If litigation against the County was discussed, the public has the right to know who threatened to sue Coffee County --- whether the Secretary of State's office <https://bradblog.comhttps//twitter.com/MarilynRMarks1/status/1545921712717537282?s=20> [57], Dominion Voting Systems, or other entities entirely --- and how the matter was resolved. *Did the threatened litigation relate to the January elections building breaches, then still a tightly held secret?* *Still more questions than answers* <https://bradblog.comhttps//twitter.com/MacFinn44/status/1365437816080109576> [58]Seeking details on the Commissioners quorum revelation, we asked County Attorneys Jennifer Herzog and Tony Rowell for comment. Our repeated messages went unanswered. So did our multiple requests for comment sent to every current Commissioner besides Oscar Paulk and every current Board of Elections member other than Andy Thomas and Ernestine Thomas-Clark. As the freshly cracking wall of secrecy surrounding that Thursday assembly 28 months ago at the Coffee County Courthouse continues to crumble, we may come to understand better the myriad links between relevant parties, such as top Trumpers, corporate voting vendors, high-powered and profoundly conflicted "local" lawyers, leading Georgia state election officials and those on the ground in Coffee County, including the public asking what happened in their home county and what should be done about it. Where did this apparent cover-up begin? Where does it end? We will keep digging. In the meantime, if you happen to see MyPillow CEO Mike Lindell, ask him what he was doing late that night at Coffee county's airport <https://bradblog.comhttps//twitter.com/MacFinn44/status/1365437816080109576> [59] in Douglas, Georgia, right after visiting the nation's capital and Donald Trump's private club, will ya? After all, he'd been photographed the month prior heading into the White House, just a week after the Jan. 6 auto-coup attempt, carrying notes mentioning Sidney Powell --- funder of the unprecedented Coffee County voting system breach --- and citing the Insurrection Act, a legal basis, in certain unhappy circumstances, for declaring martial law. That seems important. ** * ** *Originally from Texas, Douglas Lucas is a Seattle-based freelance writer/journalist, content marketer, and substitute teacher in public education. Besides speaking at a Buffalo, New York anarchist bookstore in 2017, he has reported from the trials of several federal defendants in the hacktivism/transparency movement, turned internal memos hacked out of the spy firm Stratfor into carefully researched stories, and appeared as an expert on the same in the documentary film The Hacker Wars. Visit his website <https://bradblog.comhttps//douglaslucas.com> [60], follow him on Twitter <https://bradblog.comhttps//twitter.com/DouglasLucas> [61], or admire his houseplants on Instagram <https://bradblog.comhttps//instagram.com/DouglasLucas> [62].* ------------------------------ Article printed from The BRAD BLOG: *https://bradblog.com <https://bradblog.com>* URL to article: *https://bradblog.com/?p=14697 <https://bradblog.com/?p=14697>* URLs in this post: [1] resignation letters: *https://bradblog.comhttps://douglasnow.com/index.php/news/item/8778-board-of... <http://douglasnow.com/index.php/news/item/8778-board-of-ele>ctions-accepts-employee-resignations-election-office-temporarily-closed* [2] Misty Hampton: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/MistyHamptonResignation... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/MistyHamptonResignationLett>er_25February2021.pdf* [3] her assistant: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/JilRidlehooverResignati... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/JilRidlehooverResignationLe>tter_25February2021.pdf* [4] The BRAD BLOG: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com <http://bradblog.com>* [5] flight records show: *https://bradblog.comhttps://twitter.com/MacFinn44/status/1365437816080109576 <http://twitter.com/MacFinn44/status/1365437816080109576>* [6] Evidence: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_K... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_KurtO>lsenMistyHamptonEdVoylesMessages_February2021.pdf* [7] armed and violent Trump supporters assailed: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-J6-REPORT/pdf/GP... <http://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-J6-REPORT/pdf/GPO-J6>-REPORT.pdf* [8] funded and organized: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/invoice.html <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/invoice.html>* [9] sanctioned: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.michigan.gov/-/media/Project/Websites/AG/opi... <http://www.michigan.gov/-/media/Project/Websites/AG/opinion>s/172_opinion__order_King.pdf?rev=094b2bd4f3e141a1b9bb5aff9ee2cf6a* [10] failed: *https://bradblog.comhttps://lostnotstolen.org/ <http://lostnotstolen.org/>* [11] lied: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_E... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_Exhib>itRegardingLathamLies_19September2022.pdf* [12] gravely compromised: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_H... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_Halde>rmanDominionBMDSecurityAnalysis_1July2021Unsealed14June2023.pdf* [13] more than a dozen states: *https://bradblog.comhttps://verifiedvoting.org/verifier/#mode/search/year/20... <http://verifiedvoting.org/verifier/#mode/search/year/2024/m>ake/Dominion* [14] recently put it: *https://bradblog.comhttps://youtu.be/Rjw2cIHxyfQ?t=2162 <http://youtu.be/Rjw2cIHxyfQ?t=2162>* [15] reportedly: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2023/06/02/trump-g... <http://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2023/06/02/trump-georg>ia-election-investigation-fulton-county/* [16] since learned: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/?p=14643 <http://bradblog.com/?p=14643>* [17] hatched: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/21/us/trump-voting-softw... <http://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/21/us/trump-voting-software->2020-election.html* [18] notorious December 2020 meeting: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/12/us/dec-18-meeting-jan... <http://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/12/us/dec-18-meeting-jan-6-t>rump.html* [19] testimony: *https://bradblog.comhttps://freespeechforpeople.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/... <http://freespeechforpeople.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/d>oj.sp_.coffee.j6.4.18.23.pdf* [20] investigated: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-J6-TRANSCRIPT-CT... <http://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-J6-TRANSCRIPT-CTRL00>00055541/pdf/GPO-J6-TRANSCRIPT-CTRL0000055541.pdf* [21] voting rights activist: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.vera.org/in-our-backyards-stories/this-is-by... <http://www.vera.org/in-our-backyards-stories/this-is-by-des>ign* [22] *not*: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.wsj.com/articles/listen-to-the-full-trump-ga... <http://www.wsj.com/articles/listen-to-the-full-trump-ga-cal>l-11609713527* [23] covering it all up: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/coveritallup.html <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/coveritallup.html>* [24] deposition: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_W... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_Wende>llStoneDeposition_1September2022.pdf* [25] celebratory text: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/celebratorymessage.html <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/celebratorymessage.html>* [26] unverifiable: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/?p=14693 <http://bradblog.com/?p=14693>* [27] robustly audited: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~stark/Preprints/gentle12.... <http://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~stark/Preprints/gentle12.pdf>* [28] experts: *https://bradblog.comhttps://georgetownlawtechreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2... <http://georgetownlawtechreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/>07/4.2-p523-541-Appel-Stark.pdf* [29] agree: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_H... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_Halde>rmanDominionBMDSecurityAnalysis_1July2021Unsealed14June2023.pdf* [30] found: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/?p=13101 <http://bradblog.com/?p=13101>* [31] News stories: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CGGandFSFP_SummaryOfMaj... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CGGandFSFP_SummaryOfMajorMe>diaAndMore_May2022toApril2023.pdf* [32] detailed: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.cnn.com/2022/09/06/politics/surveillance-vid... <http://www.cnn.com/2022/09/06/politics/surveillance-video-v>oting-machine-breach-coffee-county-georgia/index.html* [33] sworn December 2022 declaration: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_K... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_Kevin>SkoglundDeclaration_5December2022.pdf* [34] warns: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2023-03-30/electi... <http://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2023-03-30/election-m>achines-cpac* [35] Georgia law: *https://bradblog.comhttps://rules.sos.ga.gov/gac/183-1-12-.05?urlRedirected=yes& <http://rules.sos.ga.gov/gac/183-1-12-.05?urlRedirected=yes&>#038;data=admin&lookingfor=183-1-12-.05* [36] recommended: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.cisa.gov/news-events/ics-advisories/icsa-22-... <http://www.cisa.gov/news-events/ics-advisories/icsa-22-154->01* [37] recently told: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/?p=14659 <http://bradblog.com/?p=14659>* [38] text: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/GroupMessages_ChaneyTho... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/GroupMessages_ChaneyThomasE>ThomasClarkMcCulloughStone_24February2021.pdf* [39] minutes: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CoffeeCountyElectionsBo... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CoffeeCountyElectionsBoard_>Agenda_25February2021.pdf* [40] noticed in advance: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/MistyHamptonEricChaneyT... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/MistyHamptonEricChaneyTextM>essages_MeetingPublicNotice_FebruaryMarch2021.pdf* [41] deposition: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_E... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CurlingVRaffensperger_EricC>haneyDeposition_15August2022.pdf* [42] not a reason: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/notareason.html <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/notareason.html>* [43] 250 times: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/250.html <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/250.html>* [44] signed: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CoffeeCountyElectionsBo... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CoffeeCountyElectionsBoardP>ublicMinutes_Signed_25Feb2021ProducedOct2022.pdf* [45] Coalition for Good Governance: *https://bradblog.comhttps://coalitionforgoodgovernance.org <http://coalitionforgoodgovernance.org>* [46] concise document: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CoffeeCountyElectionsBo... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/CoffeeCountyElectionsBoardP>ublicMinutes_Unsigned_25Feb2021ProducedOct2022.pdf* [47] their website: *https://bradblog.comhttps://sos.ga.gov/ <http://sos.ga.gov/>* [48] highly vulnerable: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/?p=14693 <http://bradblog.com/?p=14693>* [49] stubbornly refused: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/stubbornrefusal.html <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/stubbornrefusal.html>* [50] boilerplate response: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/boilerplate.html <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/boilerplate.html>* [51] guide to open meetings: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.accg.org/library/legal/Open <http://www.accg.org/library/legal/Open> Meetings and Open Records Laws 2016.pdf* [52] case law: *https://bradblog.comhttps://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/AppealsCourtGeorgia_Cla... <http://bradblog.com/Docs/Coffee/AppealsCourtGeorgia_Claxton>EnterpriseVEvansCtyBdComm_6June2001.pdf* [53] Georgia open meetings law: *https://bradblog.comhttps://law.georgia.gov/document/here-4/download <http://law.georgia.gov/document/here-4/download>* [54] asked: *https://bradblog.comhttps://youtu.be/Rjw2cIHxyfQ?t=2030 <http://youtu.be/Rjw2cIHxyfQ?t=2030>* [55] County Commissioners: *https://bradblog.comhttps://qpublic.net/ga/coffee/index-com.html <http://qpublic.net/ga/coffee/index-com.html>* [56] Georgia's legislation enabling: *https://bradblog.comhttps://www.legis.ga.gov/api/legislation/document/201320... <http://www.legis.ga.gov/api/legislation/document/20132014/1>35112* [57] Secretary of State's office: *https://bradblog.comhttps://twitter.com/MarilynRMarks1/status/15459217127175... <http://twitter.com/MarilynRMarks1/status/154592171271753728>2?s=20* [58] Image: *https://bradblog.comhttps://twitter.com/MacFinn44/status/1365437816080109576 <http://twitter.com/MacFinn44/status/1365437816080109576>* [59] at Coffee county's airport: *https://bradblog.comhttps://twitter.com/MacFinn44/status/1365437816080109576 <http://twitter.com/MacFinn44/status/1365437816080109576>* [60] website: *https://bradblog.comhttps://douglaslucas.com <http://douglaslucas.com>* [61] on Twitter: *https://bradblog.comhttps://twitter.com/DouglasLucas <http://twitter.com/DouglasLucas>* [62] on Instagram: *https://bradblog.comhttps://instagram.com/DouglasLucas <http://instagram.com/DouglasLucas>* Click here <https://bradblog.com/?p=14697&print=1#Print> to print.
participants (4)
-
Douglas Lucas
-
grarpamp
-
Karl Semich
-
Undescribed Horrific Abuse, One Victim & Survivor of Many