Re: [Cryptography] Text of Burr-Feinstein encryption backdoor bill
https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/2797124/Burr-Feinstein-Encryption... https://www.burr.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/BAG16460.pdf
Lawmaking, Crypto, and Weasel Words... One Random Read Between The Lines
A BILL To require [crap] and for other purposes
Because "other purposes" is how you sneak in more unwanted crap behind the first crap. And how you avoid legitimate up or down on any single issue. Feature creep 101.
"Compliance with Court Orders Act of 2016"
Sounds dreamy and routine doesn't it, just breeze over it on a lazy Sunday in the park and vote yes on Monday. Nothing to see here, move along.
It is the sense of Congress that ...
These weasel words are particularly revolting, they smell like flowers but they're not. They vote for them because flowers... after all, their expected "sense" and thus their expected vote has already been printed on paper for them by their leaders, how could they ever vote against such pretty things. After gleefully voting for it, they then find themselves forever trapped because this "sense" has now been formally imposed upon their prior independance by law. Any dissent against the enacted flowers now becomes an embarrassing politically suicidal case of position changing, and illegal, because it's not following the official "sense". Disgusting.
(1) no person or entity is above the law
Actually, they are, at least until the law exerts itself over special selectees among them, typically reserved for dissenters.
(2) economic growth prosperity security, stability, and liberty require adherence to the rule of law
Actually, none of these *require* any law, let alone blind adherance to it.
(3) the Constitution and laws of the United States provide for the safety, security, and civil liberties of all United States persons
No, they don't, nor are there any such guarantees.
and the protections and obligations of these laws apply to all persons within United States jurisdiction
No, they don't. Notice the routine trotting out of grand patriotic bullshit like this to dispel any critical thought and bank votes on shit laws. PATRIOT even had it in its title.
(4) all providers of communications services and products (including software)
"Software"... see, they snuck in the all encompassing grandaddy of them all... any / all / your "software", including opensource and private use, and extends to hardware as software in silicon.
should protect the privacy of United States persons through implementation of appropriate data security
Stage setting under dissentproof "sense of congress" for future legislated "security". Lots of failure there. See also: CALEA Everywhere, plugin goatse version
and still respect the rule of law and comply with all legal requirements and court orders
Attempt at washing away dissent, disrespect and noncompliance as unconscionable / evil acts, or unacceptable to even think of.
(5) to uphold both the rule of law and protect the interests and security of the United States,
Wait a minute, thought this US thing was about "we the people", now it's only about "of the United States" itself?
all persons receiving an authorized judicial order
Wait a minute, judges issue their own independant orders, all the way up to the Supreme's, so now just exactly *who* is doing this "authorizing" above them? You don't think the Judicial Branch will just lay themselves over entirely to statutory law do you? Alternatively, just what is the police force of the Judiciary, and who does it report to?
for information or data must provide, in a timely manner, responsive, intelligible information or data, or appropriate technical assistance to obtain such information or data
These days, thanks to your allowing them twisting it for 15+ years, "technical assistance" now includes indefinite detention and rubberhose "tech"niques, destruction of family / work life, asset forfeiture, etc. Also, tricking and ratting out others is hip.
(6) covered entities must provide responsive, intelligible information or data, or appropriate technical assistance to a government pursuant to a court order.
All "entities" to any "a government" around the world? Nice one. Global Order [?] brought within a Sea of Pretty Flowers. Proudly passed by your Presidents and Congresses, stamped by Judges picked by same. People around the world need to be reading the crap that gets put in their laws, then getting rid of the crap that put it there.
On 03/04/2017 06:52 PM, grarpamp wrote:
https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/2797124/Burr-Feinstein-Encryption... https://www.burr.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/BAG16460.pdf
Dianne Feinstein's husband has interest in Compass Automation (/I believe they were eventually bought out by Synopsys/) . A company that makes the tools used to put backdoors in (/at least/) comm chipsets,. They probably didn't like me referring to her as a “Corrupt Bitch” when they followed their vanity search to http://auntieimperial.tumblr.com/post/54758257254
participants (2)
-
grarpamp
-
Razer