-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 On 01/20/2017 03:04 PM, jim bell wrote:
*From:* grarpamp <grarpamp@gmail.com>
Rather amazed AP hasn't yet risen (publicly) to affect things.
No disagreement from me on that! When I proposed AP almost 22 years ago, https://cryptome.org/ap.htm, I believed that the possibilities and advantages of the system would be immediately debated and decided upon. A lot of debate did indeed occur, but even today the average person remains unaware that there is a solution to militaries and war, to government and tyranny. How long until freedom breaks out and lives?
It seems to me that AP has not been implemented due to one deficit: We have no means of implementing AP with adequate safeguards to protect the operators and participants from the combined resources of military and law enforcement agencies from numerous jurisdictions worldwide. AP may be "perfectly legal" for every participant except the prize winners, but in the view of a targeted ruling class and its servants, it is perfectly legal to kill the operators on discovery as long as they do not get caught doing so. If they do get caught, they can simply change the laws. Their propaganda capabilities would assure broad public approval of any such changes. AP is a novel means of waging class warfare, but if and when it gets implemented the "enemies of the people" will not surrender or sit quietly waiting to die, constrained by rule of law from striking back with every means available to them. As these means include already established surveillance and manipulation capabilities spanning the networks AP communications must hide in to be successful, early implementations of AP would trigger an arms race. Maybe the AP side can win, but the lessons learned along the way to that victory would be paid for in the blood of failed operators. So far no one has shown up with the necessary technical capabilities and confidence to take the risk and pay the price. A fully distributed network protocol for AP, with no single or higher-value points of failure, clever enough to offer a credible (if false) promise of security to early adopters, might someday get off the ground. But given that the global industrial economy will most likely collapse first and take most of today's ruling class down with it, I think it makes more sense to wait for the laws of physics to do the job. The more hard-headed anarchistic technologists we have when that happens, the sooner a world (more) worth living in can replace the one we have. Since trying to make AP work in today's real would motivate today's ruling class to thin that particular herd, I would not encourage them to implement AP... just yet. :o) -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v2.0.22 (GNU/Linux) iQEcBAEBAgAGBQJYgpVtAAoJEECU6c5Xzmuqk28IAMFMvy0gue8nrBCxFmsuGVQv wNRoowrToMg+oA25yYuXriw0ZJ9SHba6EkkbekSKVBWQ2Be9Sq4hRi2bus/22dl4 4piYfxI/Paps2OyuvbhkPWc2HhEpIMUzzNSZONpCE6mwj8Py1LIXJHjhurnnJIoV WpTCkmzB0La31EbjBubaUB8VF6/+I03+cNOMMN4kI4360+AQjoy1ydgu7pa2lUto A2yUttyYEm8v3x1Q3c9QdjlNnO8hZ4CmhWe5yr2QX7sQ+MMiyI1EnG2oiMTjz89f GH5D5AILVz7ApFTbkU/GgikifOb4uR45Y2iJD+0zWOmVq6pD4vNgzw3hrLCdiCU= =B5lY -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----