Marc Horowitz <marc@GZA.COM> writes:

...

...

From: Clark Reynard <clark@metal.psu.edu> Excepting the Morris Worm, can you name a SINGLE Computer Emergency which CERT has halted? It is simply an organization to keep the crypto-fascists wired into the net.

My experience with them in the past has been as a clearinghouse for users to report security-related bugs to vendors, and for vendors to provide fixed back to users. They've done an admirable job at this; the major complaint is that they are too slow. They also help distribute tools like COPS to validate unix workstation security.

Granted. However, as you say, they are terribly slow and inefficient even at this. While I read CERT adisories and clippings, it is rare that I discover anything which could be called 'news.'

They are a proactive organization, not a reactive organization, so it's meaningless to ask what "Computer Emergencies" CERT has "halted".

Perhaps, then, their name is inappropriate. The term "Computer" seems to imply they are involved with computers. This is true. However, "Emergency," when modified by "Computer," seems to indicate that they are involved in some way with "Computer Emergencies," whatever this means. When combined with "Response," the previous terms seem to imply that they are intended to "Respond" to "Computer Emergencies," which, as you say, they don't do. They ought to change their name, or find some computer emergencies to which to respond.

I think that calling them "crypto-fascists" is at best an unsupported smear, and at worst slanderous.

A quibble: I believe you mean 'libellous.' They are crypto-fascists; that is to say, they are 'hidden' fascists. (However, I'll grant that calling them fascists is probably not productive, however amusing it may be.) [Peter Honeyman's comments deleted.]

I agree with Peter. If CERT is beginning to overstep its bounds. perhaps someone should make a calm, rational complaint.

I shall do so. Don't worry, I won't call them crypto-fascists. I shall forward it when I send it. ---- Robert W. F. Clark Stop the Clipper Chip rclark@nyx.cs.du.edu Proposal! clark@metal.psu.edu