David, Thanks for the Wired pointer. From reading Declan's article it is not anymore clear now what Brian West did or did not do than before -- maybe less so now -- because most of the information about latest developments has come from the feds, and Declan does not appear to have done thorough checking the feds' version with other sources, and indeed has put an unfortunate slant in his story not yet objectively supportable. You must know that the feds often put out misleading press releases, especially in cases with high media coverage, and most especially when they have made a well-publicized mistake. The story is not yet out about the complete Brian West story, as with predecessor stories about compsec cases and plea bargains and, worse, rush to judgment convictions. I am not being crotchety just awaiting information that does not too quickly help obscure the current law enforcement practice of demonizing all compsec complaints made by poorly secured sites operators and plea bargaining of coerced targets. This case still appears to be that kind of witchhunting loose upon the "defenseless" homeland. John At 02:15 PM 9/27/01 -0400, you wrote:
He pled guilty and admitted he'd been up to no good; he wasn't an innocent victim of an overzealous Justice Department
On Fri, Sep 28, 2001 at 10:38:09AM -0700, John Young wrote:
about latest developments has come from the feds, and Declan does not appear to have done thorough checking the feds' version with other sources
This is incorrect. My article was based on conversations with defense counsel and supporters, including an off-the record conversation that I could not use in the article, conversations with the Feds, a review of earlier correspondence (http://www.politechbot.com/cgi-bin/politech.cgi?name=sperling) in the case, a review of the statute in question here, a review of affidavits filed in the case, and the plea agreement that West signed. It's easy to flame on a mailing list. Knowing what you're talking about it a bit more difficult. -Declan
participants (2)
-
Declan McCullagh
-
John Young