Tim May wrote:
Does anybody remember 10+ years ago when a "Driver's License" wasn't quite a National ID Card or a Citizenship Credential or a Probably-Not-A-Deadbeat-Dad Right-to-Work Card, or a Homeland Security Internal Passport, or an Identity Theft Leverage Device, but merely intended to indicate that you knew how to drive? (OK, and that it was therefore ok for you to drink :-) There was a bit of control added in the mid 80s to reduce the extent to which people could ditch bad driving records by moving or by having multiple licenses simultaneously, but it was basically about driving. Pete Wilson, who as the CA electrical system market failure demonstrates, was a Social Conservative type Republican rather than a Fiscal Responsibility or Small Government type Republican, decided that it wasn't safe for people to drive while speaking Spanish, so he got the CA legislature to ban it. They gradually either became more liberal or more Spanish or influenced by different pressure groups and tried to change it, and Gray Davis at first opposed it before deciding he needed the votes of Mexican-Americans who were US citizens and changed his mind, and now people who should know better are ragging on him about it. I immigrated here to California about the time they were waffling back and forth about whether to require citizenship papers to be in order to get a driver's license or whether they'd accept a New Jersey driver's license.
On Mon, Sep 15, 2003 at 04:07:02PM -0700, Bill Stewart wrote: | Tim May wrote: | > http://vikingphoenix.com/immigration/davis_sign_illegal.htm | | Does anybody remember 10+ years ago when a "Driver's License" | wasn't quite a National ID Card or a Citizenship Credential Yeah. The real problem with all these other uses is that they create a negative feedback loop: the more useful the card is, the more people are motivated to get involved in "fradulent issue," and the more rationalizations there are for DMV employees to engage in it. So we spend more and more to secure the cards, and the only people who win are the hologram manufacturers. Unfortunately, the people actually relying on the cards don't realize this as fast as the users of the system. Adam -- "It is seldom that liberty of any kind is lost all at once." -Hume
participants (3)
-
Adam Shostack
-
Bill Stewart
-
Tim May