When confronted with calls to "Do something!" or "We can't just stand by and watch!," I think of one word: "So?" "If we don't intervene in Yakistan, the Pothurden minority will be brutalized!" "So?" "If we don't subsidize the production of ethanol, it will not succeed." "So?" "If we as a nation don't launch a major effort to land a man on Mars, it won't happen!" "So?" "We need to rebuild the World Trade Center, else America will have been defeated by the terrorists." "So?" "If we don't do something about online porn, it will get worse." "So?" Asking "So?" is a powerful antidote to what frequently crops up as a kind of debating error. (It may even have some Latin name, but I don't know it.) This error can be summarized as: Assumes a solution is required. Implies that there is some problem which must be resolved, which agreement must be reached on. Thus, we must solve the problem in Yakistan, or the problem of ethanol cost, or Mars colonization, online porn, etc. Asking "So?" says succinctly that the problem posed is not accepted as a problem which needs collective (or taxpayer-funded) solving. It also causes the other party, at least in some cases, to step back and attempt to explain why the "ethanol problem" or the "pornography problem" needs to be solved, instead of simply assuming it's a problem requiring collective solving with the only argument being how best to solve it. I find it refreshing to think this way. I believe I first heard this point of view articulated in this simple form by Chip Morningstar, but it certainly is consistent with the libertarian points of view of Harry Browne, P.J. O'Rourke, and others. Just Say "So?"
on Mon, Oct 01, 2001 at 01:24:29PM -0700, Tim May (tcmay@got.net) wrote:
When confronted with calls to "Do something!" or "We can't just stand by and watch!," I think of one word: "So?"
There's an alternative formulation: Don't just do something. Stand there. The gist is the same. Senseless activity isn't justified by virtue of being activity. Peace. -- Karsten M. Self <kmself@ix.netcom.com> http://kmself.home.netcom.com/ What part of "Gestalt" don't you understand? Home of the brave http://gestalt-system.sourceforge.net/ Land of the free Free Dmitry! Boycott Adobe! Repeal the DMCA! http://www.freesklyarov.org Geek for Hire http://kmself.home.netcom.com/resume.html [demime 0.97c removed an attachment of type application/pgp-signature]
participants (2)
-
Karsten M. Self
-
Tim May