[Retransmission. Due to periodic problems with lne.com, I started sending my messages to ssz.com a few days ago. Alas, ssz.com has had an outage. Hence these retransmissions. Sorry for any dupes.] Begin forwarded message:
From: Tim May <tcmay@got.net> Date: Tue Dec 04, 2001 08:56:01 AM US/Pacific To: cypherpunks@einstein.ssz.com Subject: Re: Reputation capital
On Tuesday, December 4, 2001, at 05:28 AM, Marcel Popescu wrote:
I think all this stuff about reputations is being solved pretty neatly by the credit bureaus... up to getting scalars on people / companies.
Mark
This is naive. Credit bureaus handle only a particular class of reputations, certain types of credit-worthiness, and then with well-documented deep flaws:
-- regulation by government
-- "Fair Credit Reporting Act" forbids them from "remembering" certain classes of defaults and welshings
-- lack of competition (the Three use the same precise standards)
If you are rejoining the discussions after a long absence, you need to get up to speed.
--Tim May "The Constitution is a radical document...it is the job of the government to rein in people's rights." --President William J. Clinton
--Tim May "That government is best which governs not at all." --Henry David Thoreau
On Wed, Dec 05, 2001 at 08:07:47AM -0800, Tim May wrote:
[Retransmission. Due to periodic problems with lne.com, I started sending my messages to ssz.com a few days ago. Alas, ssz.com has had an outage. Hence these retransmissions. Sorry for any dupes.]
The problems lne was having have been fixed. My MX host had an extra '.' in their MailerHosts table, so mail to anything@lne.com that got MXd to them was being rejected with 'User unknown'. Eric
From: "Tim May" <tcmay@got.net>
I think all this stuff about reputations is being solved pretty neatly by the credit bureaus... up to getting scalars on people / companies.
This is naive. Credit bureaus handle only a particular class of reputations, certain types of credit-worthiness, and then with well-documented deep flaws:
Ok, I agree I was too happy to have found something connected to this :) Let's say there APPEARS to be a solution, at least to a class of problems - trade reputations - and the credit bureaus MIGHT BE a good start in that direction. (And apparently a good second step would be the removal of the flaws you mention.) Also, regarding the flaws: something like this would be a HUGE improvement over the current situation in many countries (mine included). Mark
participants (3)
-
Eric Murray
-
Marcel Popescu
-
Tim May