On Wed, 16 Oct 1996, IPG Sales wrote:
Some of you have sardonically written to say "Nihil Est Demonstrandum," N.E.D. because an OTP must be derived from a hardware source, that is, it must be a pure random sequence of limitless entropy. Accordingly, they unbashfully assert that an OTP generated by a computer program is not possible.
How do they know that? Does the Bible tell them so, or the Koran, or do they get it from the Torah? Why not cite the source of their certainty instead of advancing an unsupported proposition. I do not mean to be rude, but excuse me, what scientific proof can they offer for that immovable avowal? There is no scientific proof whatsoever, none at all, except for the words and their steadfast, and maybe self serving, postulate. Accordingly, obviously it is they, not us, who are the ones that have "Nihil Est Demonstrandum," in this matter. There is not one scintilla of sustainable evidence to support such a doctrine.
Any algorithmic generation (which all software is) is predictable given the algorithm. If its not hardware based, it can be guessed. This is altogether obvious. tough luck. --Deviant Blood flows down one leg and up the other.