Of course you _have_ that right; I was writing in response to the assertion that the _Constitution_ says you have it, when in fact it not only says no such thing, but the Supremes have occasionally ruled substantially differently. I agree with Jim Choate that the 9th and 10th leave room for all sorts of rights that nobody in their right mind would disagree with but which the government keeps trying to take away anyway.... but that's no excuse for claiming that things are explicitly stated there when they're not. At 04:40 PM 1/11/98 -0400, The Sheriff wrote:
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
At 8:26 PM -0800 1/10/98, Bill Stewart wrote:
Umm, no, freedom doesn't work like that. If you open a *private* establishment, you have the right, according to the constitution, to deny *anyone* the right to enter or eat in your restraunt.
I don't see freedom of association listed anywhere there; you might construe it as a "taking" or something, but it'd be a stretch. Also, there was a really appalling court case in the 1890s (Plessey vs. Ferguson), in which the Supremes ruled that states could require segregation with separate but equal accommodations; it was somewhat overturned by Brown vs. Board of Education in 1954, but the idea that the government can tell you how to run your business is long established (after all, we'd need much smaller governments if they couldn't be interfering in business.)
Firstly, something being long-established doesn't make it right. SO, let's look at it this way, regarding the freedom of association.
You have the freedom to associate with whom you choose, don't you think? It's not in the constitution, but you would throw a fit if Uncle Sam told you that it was illegal for you to go play baseball with little Billy if little Billy was black and you were white.
AND, in my not so humble opinion, If you have the freedom to play with little Billy, then you have the freedom to tell little Billy to go fuck himself because you refuse to play with "niggers."
Thanks! Bill Bill Stewart, bill.stewart@pobox.com PGP Fingerprint D454 E202 CBC8 40BF 3C85 B884 0ABE 4639