Also at: https://gitweb.torproject.org/user/mikeperry/torspec.git/blob/mapaddress-che... --------------------------------------------------------------- Title: Internal Mapaddress for Tor Configuration Testing Author: Mike Perry Created: 08-10-2012 Status: Open Target: 0.2.4.x+ Overview This proposal describes a method by which we can replace the https://check.torproject.org/ testing service with an internal XML document provided by the Tor client. Motivation The Tor Check service is a central point of failure in terms of Tor usability. If it is ever out of sync with the set of exit nodes on the Tor network or down, user experience is degraded considerably. Moreover, the check itself is very time-consuming. Users must wait seconds or more for the result to come back. Worse still, if the user's software *was* in fact misconfigured, the check.torproject.org DNS resolution and request leaks out on to the network. Design Overview The system will have three parts: an internal hard-coded IP address mapping (127.84.111.114:80), a hard-coded mapaddress to a DNS name (selftest.torproject.org:80), and a DirPortFrontPage-style simple HTTP server that serves an XML document for both addresses. Upon receipt of a request to the IP address mapping, the system will create a new 128 bit randomly generated nonce and provide it in the XML document. Requests to http://selftest.torproject.org/ must include a valid, recent nonce as the GET url path. Upon receipt of a valid nonce, it is removed from the list of valid nonces. Nonces are only valid for 60 seconds or until SIGNAL NEWNYM, which ever comes first. The list of pending nonces should not be allowed to grow beyond 10 entries. The timeout period and nonce limit should be configurable in torrc. Design: XML document format for http://127.84.111.114 To avoid the need to localize the message in Tor, Tor will only provide a XML object with connectivity information. Here is an example form: <tor-test> <tor-bootstrap-percent>100</tor-bootstrap-percent> <tor-version-current>true</tor-version-current> <dns-nonce>4977eb4842c7c59fa5b830ac4da896d9</dns-nonce> <tor-test/> The tor-bootstrap-percent field represents the results of the Tor client bootstrap status as integer percentages from bootstrap_status_t. The tor-version-current field represents the results of the Tor client consensus version check. If the bootstrap process has not yet downloaded a consensus document, this field will have the value null. The dns-nonce field contains a 128-bit secret, encoded in base16. This field is only present for requests that list the Host: header as 127.84.111.114. Design: XML document format for http://selftest.torproject.org/nonce <tor-test> <tor-bootstrap-percent>100</tor-bootstrap-percent> <tor-version-current>true</tor-version-current> <dns-nonce-valid>true</dns-nonce-valid> <tor-test/> The first two fields are the same as for the IP address version. The dns-nonce-valid field is only true if the Host header matches selftest.torproject.org and the nonce is current and valid. Upon receipt of a valid nonce, that nonce is removed from the list of valid nonces. Design: Request Servicing Care must be taken with the dns-nonce generation and usage, to prevent users from being tracked through leakage of nonce value to application content. While the usage of XML appears to make this impossible due to stricter same-origin policy enforcement than JSON, same-origin enforcement is still fraught with exceptions and loopholes. In particular: Any requests that contain the Origin: header MUST be ignored, as the Origin: header is only included for third party web content (CORS). dns-nonce fields MUST be omitted if the HTTP Host: header does not match the IP address 127.84.111.114. Requests to selftest.torproject.org MUST return false for the dns-nonce-valid field if the HTTP Host: header does not match selftest.torproject.org, regardless of nonce value. Further, requests to selftest.torproject.org MUST validate that 'selftest.torproject.org' was the actual hostname provided to SOCKS4A, and not some alternate address mapping (due to DNS rebinding attacks, for example). Design: Application Usage Applications will use the system in two steps. First, they will make an HTTP request to http://127.84.111.114:80/ over Tor's SOCKS port and parse the resulting XML, if any. If the request at this stage fails, the application should inform the user that either their Tor client is too old, or that it is misconfigured, depending upon the nature of the failure. If the request succeeds and valid XML is returned, the application will record the value of the dns-nonce field, and then perform a second request to http://selftest.torproject.org/nonce_value. If the second request succeeds, and the dns-nonce-valid field is true, the application may inform the user that their Tor settings are valid. If the second request fails, or does not provide the correct dns-nonce, the application will inform the user that their Tor DNS proxy settings are incorrect. If either tor-bootstrap-percent is not 100, or tor-version-current is false, applications may choose to inform the user of these facts using properly localized strings and appropriate UI. Security Considerations XML was chosen over JSON due to the risks of the identifier leaking in a way that could enable websites to track the user[1]. Because there are many exceptions and circumvention techniques to the same-origin policy, we have also opted for strict controls on dns-nonce lifetimes and usage, as well as validation of the Host header and SOCKS4A request hostnames. 1. http://www.hpenterprisesecurity.com/vulncat/en/vulncat/dotnet/javascript_hij... -- Mike Perry _______________________________________________ tor-dev mailing list tor-dev@lists.torproject.org https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev ----- End forwarded message ----- -- Eugen* Leitl <a href="http://leitl.org">leitl</a> http://leitl.org ______________________________________________________________ ICBM: 48.07100, 11.36820 http://www.ativel.com http://postbiota.org 8B29F6BE: 099D 78BA 2FD3 B014 B08A 7779 75B0 2443 8B29 F6BE