-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Issues: 1. Robustness. Usenet wins. 2. Efficiency. Usenet loses, but perhaps some kind of hack could be implemented combining mail and news delivery for greater efficiency without losing robustness? I'm not familiar with NNTP. 3. Access control. Usenet is too easy to get in to. We need to discourage clueless newbies from bothering us. This too could be hacked, e.g. set up a PGP cancel bot which only allows PGP signed posts. (This has many other convenient benefits such as encouraging nyms, and preventing spam.) Hm.. But people might worry that sigs could increase their legal exposure, even if they use (less than perfectly strong) nyms. So a good variation is to generate the canonical key pair and share the secret key around. Hell, post the secret key once a week in the FAQ... The cancel bot should allow sigs by either that key or any arbitrary key. Whoops! Such a cancel-bot undermines our goal of robustness.. HMMMmm. Okay the best solution to signal/noise management is (as always) filtering at the reader's desk. I don't read William H. Geiger III or Paul Bradley posts (usually), I don't read anything Subject: "Make Money Fast", from "Graham-John Buellers" or containing "Timmy" in the first sentence, and if we switch to Usenet, I won't read articles posted by unknowns without PGP sigs. There. :-) Regards, Zooko P.S. I am not a crook. Nor am I the anonymous who is so earnestly pleading for some sanity-checking around here, although I tend to agree with some of his points. P.P.S. Hi, Joichi Ito! Nice to see some articles from the Japanese chapter of The International Committee to Put The Bastards Up Against A Wall--- whoops- I mean, the Japanese chapter of the Peace-Loving, Code-Writing, Money-Making Cypherpunks. -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: 2.6.3ia Charset: noconv Comment: http://www.c2.net/~bryce -- 'BAP' Easy-PGP v1.01 iQCVAwUBNG3T6hiDTlaqCaKdAQGTBwP+MFtiUEyD0zMCmhTUXA6vz4Ije/2qvPEP ckhFUlw4qLDg0cW0uXsS6Dl4HKhIV9Iu8DtC8BA7C692vC6E6EH5xQIQW6BmajOp gxhECxeCT2zrtGRKwDV5GMEtLsJ5Splp7qxlGJW4o1/16rhGVpxWzqESgC8PhDaT uAyb49at0pM= =HMRX -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----